This week, we’re diving into City Lights Theater Company’s production of Dial M for Murder and sharing our thoughts on this suspenseful, classic thriller. We talk about the performances, staging, and what makes this production such an engaging night of theatre. 🔍🎭

We also take some time at the top of the episode to share a personal update about our decision to step away from the SF Bay Area Critics Circle and what’s next for us as Broadway with AJ and Sarah continues to grow.

⸻

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week’s episode is exactly what the title promises — a little bit of everything. We’re recapping AJ’s packed weekend of shows and sharing some candid theatre thoughts along the way.

We're also talking Hillbarn Theatre’s production of Songs for a New World and feature interviews with the show’s current stars — Sophie, Jessica, and Coleton — about stepping into Jason Robert Brown’s powerful song cycle and what this production means to them. 🎶✨

Plus, we chat about the newly announced seasons at ATG SF and Broadway San Jose, sharing what we’re excited about and what’s on our must-see lists.

____

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re heading to Foothill Music Theatre to talk about The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee! 🐝✨ We share our experience with this quirky, heartfelt musical and discuss the performances, comedic timing, and audience interaction that make the show such a fan favorite.

We break down what stood out to us in this production, how the cast handled the improv-heavy moments, and why Spelling Bee continues to resonate with audiences through its humor and surprising emotional depth.

____

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re sitting down with Dedrick Weathersby to talk about the creation and evolution of Tutti Fruiti: The Musical. In our conversation, he shares how the show was first conceived, the inspiration behind the story, and the creative journey of bringing it to life. 🎭✨

We also talk about what’s next for Tutti Fruiti, including future plans to take the show to new audiences and expand its reach. It’s an insightful and forward-looking conversation about developing new work and building momentum in musical theatre.

⸻

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re sharing our thoughts on The Notebook at ATG San Francisco and diving into this sweeping, emotional stage adaptation of the beloved story. 💙

We talk about how the production brings the romance to life onstage, the performances that stood out to us, the musical score, and how the show balances intimacy with spectacle. From the storytelling choices to the overall emotional impact, we break down what resonated with us and how this adaptation translates such a well-known film to live theatre.

It’s a heartfelt, reflective episode about love, memory, and what makes this story connect with audiences in a new way.

⸻

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re diving into A.C.T.’s striking and unconventional production of A Streetcar Named Desire. In this episode, it’s just us talking through our experience with this super unique rendition of Tennessee Williams’ classic.

We discuss the bold directorial choices, performances, design elements, and how this production reimagines a familiar story in a way that feels fresh, challenging, and very intentional. From moments that surprised us to ideas that sparked conversation long after the curtain call, we break down what stood out and how this version differs from more traditional stagings.

It’s a thoughtful, reflective episode about risk-taking in theatre and what happens when a classic is approached from a new perspective.

____

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re heading to Paper Wing Theatre & Supper Club to talk about our night seeing Gutenberg! The Musical! — and especially what it’s like experiencing this show as a full dinner theatre event. 🍽️🎭

We spend a lot of time discussing the supper club atmosphere, how the food-and-show setup shapes the evening, and why Paper Wing’s intimate dining experience makes this production feel even more immersive and fun. Along the way, we also share our thoughts on the performances, the show’s clever humor, and how Gutenberg! thrives in a space where the audience feels like part of the room.

It’s a cozy, laugh-filled episode all about theatre, food, and the joy of a truly unique night out. ✨

____

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah

This week, we’re diving into BroadwaySF’s production of The Book of Mormon and sharing our experience with this bold, hilarious, and wildly energetic musical. We talk about the performances, comedy, and why the show continues to resonate with audiences years after its premiere. 🎭😂

We also got to chat with Shafiq, who plays the General, about stepping into such a memorable role, navigating the show’s intense humor, and what it’s like performing in one of Broadway’s most iconic musicals. It’s a fun, candid conversation paired with our thoughts on this touring production.

⸻

🌐 See more episodes: broadwaywithajandsarah.com

📱 Follow us on Instagram & Facebook: @BroadwayWithAJAndSarah