Merinda and Mike dive into the documentary chronicling Eternal Values, the New York new age group built around self-styled guru Frederick von Mierers — and the model, Hoyt Richards, who spent years inside it. It starts on a Nantucket beach in 1978, with talk of alien walk-ins, past lives on the star Arcturus, and a coming tribulation only Frederick's followers are prepared for. It ends with a mercy killing, a mutiny, and a group scattered in the late '90s.

Along the way: a modeling career that seems to prove Frederick's teachings are working, a compound in Lake Lure, NC built to house alien spacecraft, an "antichrist" scandal, a Richard Bey talk show appearance gone sideways, and a Vanity Fair exposé that blew the whole thing open.

Merinda and Mike break down whether this one hits all the "cult doc" genre's usual beats (charismatic leader, mind control, communal living, aliens, guns, deprogramming) and ask a bigger question: how many more stories like this one are still waiting to be told?

Plus, this week's Cult Favorites: Merinda recommends The Waterless Sea: A Curious History of Mirages by Christopher Pinney and Mike makes the case for Love Is Blind UK Season 3.

Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @cultfavoritepod, and be sure to subscribe and leave a rating and review.

Special thanks to the REL Digital Lab in the Department of Religious Studies at the University of Alabama for production assistance and our production intern Sierra Ruden.

The views expressed in this episode are our own as experts and researchers in religious studies and do not represent the University of Alabama.

Theme music produced with Udio.