Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something smooth and then go somewhere that was absolutely not smooth for the FBI in 1947.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin is behind the camera, confirmed present, no further comment — crack open Coppercraft 9 Year Straight Bourbon from Holland, Michigan and dig into one of the most chaotic weeks in American UFO history: the Twin Falls Flying Saucer Hoax of July 1947.

Three weeks after pilot Kenneth Arnold coined the term “flying saucer” near Mount Rainier, Idaho was already deep in disc fever. A forest ranger and his partner had spotted eight to ten shining objects in a V-formation over Galena Summit. Sixty picnickers had seen something they couldn’t explain. A railway foreman had made his own report. And then, on July 11, 1947, four teenagers in Twin Falls placed a 30-inch disc built from drum cymbals, plexiglass, radio parts, and aluminium foil into a neighbour’s yard at 2:30 in the morning. The FBI was notified. Three Army officers flew in from Fort Douglas, Utah to examine it. Photos were confiscated. The disc was removed to Salt Lake City. And when the teenagers confessed — it was all a joke — the secrecy continued anyway, and the local newspaper printed an editorial asking why the government was being so cagey about something they knew was fake. Sound familiar?

(Kevin is behind the camera. He was also not responsible for the 1947 disc. We checked.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE

Coppercraft 9 Year Straight Bourbon Whiskey | Small Batch | Coppercraft Distillery, Holland, Michigan

Coppercraft blends barrels of 9+ year old sourced bourbons using brandy blending and proofing techniques that take three months from barrel to bottle — a deliberate, patient process that sets it apart from standard small-batch production. Michigan-made, award-winning, and smooth enough to hold up through a two-hour debate about government secrecy.

Proof: 90.6 (45.3% ABV) | 9+ years aged | Small batch | Blended using brandy proofing techniques

Character: rich and smooth with a balanced sweetness from the extended ageing — caramel and vanilla on the nose leading into warm oak, dark fruit, and baking spice, with a long, clean finish.

Awards: Gold Medal — San Francisco World Spirits Competition 2026.

Learn more: coppercraftdistillery.com

SUBSCRIBE

New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #TwinFallsUFO, #FlyingSaucerHoax, #UFO1947, #FlyingSaucer, #CoppercraftBourbon, #CoppercraftDistillery, #BourbonPodcast, #UFOConspiracy, #Kenneth Arnold

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something worth finding and then go looking for something that might not want to be found.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin crack open Eagle Rare 10 Year — the allocated Buffalo Trace gem that somehow still sits around $40 when you can actually find it — and dig into Idaho’s own lake monster: Sharlie, the creature of Payette Lake near McCall.

Since at least 1920, a large serpentine creature — 30 to 40 feet long, humped back, small dinosaur-like head, and moving with a wake like a motorboat with no boat in sight — has been reported in Payette Lake's 392-foot glacier-carved depths. In 1944, 30 people saw it, Time Magazine ran the story, and monster hunters descended on McCall. In 1946, a physician in a group of 20 watched it dive and resurface for an extended period. In 1954, the town held a national naming contest — won by a woman from Virginia with a punchline from a radio comedy show. In 1985, the Idaho Fish and Game's own fisheries biologist said maybe Sharlie is just smarter than us. A 2023 video went viral. And nobody has ever proven what it is.

(Kevin is behind the camera. As always. We have accepted this.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE
Eagle Rare 10 Year | Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, KY
From the same distillery as Pappy Van Winkle, Blanton’s, and George T. Stagg. Eagle Rare uses Buffalo Trace’s Mashbill #1 — a low-rye recipe (believed to be approximately 75% corn, 10% rye, 15% malted barley, though Buffalo Trace has never officially confirmed the ratios) — and is aged a minimum of 10 years with every barrel hand-selected. Originally launched at 101 proof in 1975, it’s been bottled at 90 proof since 2005. One of the most sought-after bourbons at its price point; allocation is the main obstacle to finding it.
Proof: 90 (45% ABV) | Aged minimum 10 years | Low-rye Mashbill #1 | New charred oak
Nose: Toffee, honey, and leather. Palate: Bold, dry, and delicate — caramel, dark fruit, oak, and cocoa, with candied almonds and a rich mouthfeel. Finish: Dry, long, and lingering with warm oak, almond, and a touch of spice.

WHAT WE COVER
• The lake: Payette Lake, McCall, Idaho — 392 feet deep, glacier-carved, and fed by mountain snowmelt
• Native American oral tradition: the peoples who summered in Long Valley were afraid of the lake before any Western account existed
• 1920: the railroad logging crew who watched a log start moving under its own power
• 1944: 30 witnesses, national media, and Time Magazine
• 1946: a physician in a group of 20 watches it dive and resurface
• 1954: the naming contest, the winning entry, and why the name is literally a joke about credibility
• 1985: the Idaho Fish and Game fisheries biologist who said maybe it’s just smarter than us
• 2023: the viral video that briefly made Sharlie a national story again
• Eagle Rare 10 Year: the Buffalo Trace backstory, the allocation struggle, and tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #Sharlie, #PayetteLake, #IdahoLakeMonster, #LakeMonster, #EagleRare, #EagleRare10Year, #BourbonPodcast, #Cryptid, #UrbanLegends

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something smooth and then go somewhere the smell is anything but.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin is behind the camera, present and accounted for — open Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon and dig into one of the most dramatic and well-documented cryptid cases in American history: Momo, the Missouri Monster.

In the summer of 1972, a 4-foot bipedal creature covered in black matted fur, with a pumpkin-shaped head and glowing orange eyes, began terrorising the town of Louisiana, Missouri. The smell alone — described by every witness as an overwhelming rotting stench that arrived before the creature and lingered after it — sent residents scrambling. Then the fire department chief saw it in his headlights. Then a deputy fired a gunshot at it and it walked calmly to the guardrail, made eye contact, and stepped into the river. No blood trail found. Within two months a town of 4,000 people had armed posses in the woods, CBS and NBC had sent news crews, and local radio was offering a $1,000 reward. And then it stopped. Completely. No explanation. No body. Nothing.

Justin and Jeff break down 70 years of Momo sightings — from 1955 all the way through 2016 — and debate whether the iguana theory actually holds up, what the 1955 spark-emitting wand means for every conventional explanation, and why the fire department chief’s headlight sighting is the detail nobody can dismiss. Kevin is there. With the camera.

(Kevin is behind the camera. As always. We’ve stopped questioning this arrangement.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE
Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Lux Row Distillers, Bardstown, KY
An honest Kentucky sour mash bourbon that does exactly what it says. Starts with genuine Kentucky sour mash, aged the old-fashioned way, charcoal filtered, and bottled at a straightforward 90 proof. No gimmicks, no over-engineering — just a clean, approachable bourbon that holds up in the glass through a long episode.
Grains: corn, rye, and barley | Proof: 90 (45% ABV) | Charcoal filtered | Kentucky sour mash
Tasting notes: caramel and vanilla upfront with hints of spice and chocolate, finishing smooth and warm.
Awards: Platinum Medal — SIP Awards 2018, Double Gold Medal — San Francisco World Spirits Competition 2018.
Learn more: ezrabrooks.com

WHAT WE COVER
• The 1955 Branch Hill encounter: three creatures, a spark-emitting wand, and a smell of almonds and alfalfa
• The 1971 Highway 79 encounter: two women, a stolen lunch, and an early independent sighting
• July 11, 1972: the Harrison children, the pumpkin-shaped head, and the creature carrying a dead dog
• The fire department chief and city councillor who saw it in his headlights
• Deputy Matthews who fired one shot — and it stepped over the guardrail and walked into the river
• CBS, NBC, armed posses, and a $1,000 unclaimed reward
• Why the wand from 1955 breaks every conventional explanation
• The iguana theory — and its significant problems
• Why the perfect, unexplained stop is one of the most suspicious details of all
• Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon: tasting notes and the sour mash tradition


SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #MissouriMomo, #Momo, #MissouriMonster, #Cryptid, #Bigfoot, #EzraBrooks, #KentuckyBourbon, #BourbonPodcast, #UrbanLegends

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something real and then question whether anything else online is.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin is once again behind the camera, a real human, we can verify this — open an Idaho-exclusive bottle of Chicken Cock 5 Year Private Cask Kentucky Straight Bourbon and debate one of the most unsettling conspiracy theories of the digital age: the Dead Internet Theory.

The theory: starting around 2016, the majority of content you encounter online stopped being made by real people. Bots, large language models, and AI content farms now generate the bulk of posts, comments, trending topics, and entire accounts — while a shrinking minority of actual humans scroll through the synthetic result. And in 2024, bot traffic officially crossed 51% of all web activity for the first time. This isn’t fringe anymore. Sam Altman — the CEO of OpenAI, the man who makes ChatGPT — posted on X that he’s starting to see LLM-run accounts multiplying everywhere. Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian said publicly that the Dead Internet Theory is real. And a social network called Moltbook launched in January 2026 specifically for AI agents, and 1.4 million joined in the first few days. Justin makes the case for why this is more serious than anyone admits. Jeff pushes back. Kevin operates the camera and is definitely a human.

(Kevin is behind the camera. He is real. He is human. We asked him to confirm this and he did. That’s all we have.)

WHISKEY OF THE EPISODE
Chicken Cock 5 Year Private Cask | Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Idaho Exclusive | Chicken Cock Whiskey / Grain & Barrel Spirits, Bardstown, KY
Chicken Cock Whiskey traces its roots to 1856 in Paris, Kentucky — one of America’s oldest whiskey brands, revived by Grain & Barrel Spirits in Bardstown. In 2019, they laid down a reserve of their Kentucky Straight Bourbon. After a 5-year rest, the master distiller hand-selected and curated each barrel for this special private cask release. The standard bottling is a Distillery Exclusive available only at Circa 1856 in Bardstown — this bottle is an Idaho-exclusive variant, making it rarer still.
Proof: 122.9 (61.45% ABV) | Cask strength | 5 years aged | Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Character: a full-proof, cask-strength expression with the depth and intensity that comes from five years of undiluted barrel development — bold oak, caramel, and vanilla leading into a long warming finish with the heat you expect from 122.9 proof done right.
Learn more: chickencockwhiskey.com

WHAT WE COVER
• What the Dead Internet Theory actually claims — and what it felt like before
• IlluminatiPirate’s 2021 Agora Road post that started it all
• The data: 51% bot traffic (Imperva 2024), 52% of new articles AI-generated, 1,000+ AI-run fake news sites
• Sam Altman admitting he can see LLM-run accounts multiplying on X
• Alexis Ohanian saying at TechCrunch Disrupt that the Dead Internet Theory is real
• Moltbook: a social network for AI agents that got 1.4 million AI members in days
• The Digg relaunch that collapsed in 60 days because of bots
• The Internet Research Agency: documented proof governments have done this at scale
• Chicken Cock 5 Year Private Cask: the 1856 origin story, the Idaho exclusive, and tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #DeadInternetTheory, #DeadInternet, #BotTraffic, #AIContent, #InternetConspiracy, #ChickenCockWhiskey, #PrivateCaskBourbon, #BourbonPodcast, #ConspiracyTheory

Welcome to a Bourbon Legends bonus episode — no conspiracy theories this week. Just three guys, a great bottle, and the list that’s been waiting to happen.

Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin is on camera this time, confirmed, visible, present — crack open Seven Devils Caldwell Night Rodeo Whiskey from Koenig Distillery in Caldwell, Idaho, and run through their personal top 10ish games of all time. No rules. No rankings methodology. Just strong opinions, honest debate, and at least one choice that’s going to start a fight.

Expect disagreements, nostalgia, games you forgot existed, and at least one pick someone deeply regrets making in front of the camera. Kevin’s list alone is worth the runtime.

(Kevin is here. On camera. This is a historic occasion. We poured a special bottle for the occasion.)

WHISKEY OF THE EPISODE
Seven Devils Caldwell Night Rodeo Whiskey | Limited Edition | Koenig Distillery, Caldwell, Idaho
Koenig Distillery is one of the first distilleries in Idaho, with Master Distiller Andy Koenig blending every expression with water drawn from the snow-topped peaks of Idaho’s Seven Devils mountain range. The Caldwell Night Rodeo is a limited edition crafted in small batches to commemorate the annual Caldwell Night Rodeo — Koenig Distillery is the Official Whiskey of the event.
High rye mash bill | Aged in new charred American white oak barrels | Proof: 100 (50% ABV) | Limited Edition
Character: the high rye content delivers a smooth but notably spicy finish, balanced by the warmth of American white oak. Bold enough to hold up neat but approachable enough that the argument about which game belongs on the list never stops.
Learn more: koenigdistillery.com

WHAT TO EXPECT
• Justin’s top 10ish games — ranked, explained, and defended
• Jeff’s top 10ish games — where they agree and where it gets heated
• Kevin’s list — finally on camera, finally accountable
• The games that almost made the list and why they didn’t
• The one pick that everyone is going to argue about in the comments
• Seven Devils Caldwell Night Rodeo: Idaho craft distilling, the rodeo story, and tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #Top10Games, #BestGamesEver, #GamingPodcast, #SevenDevilsWhiskey, #KoenigDistillery, #CaldwellNightRodeo, #BonusEpisode, #GamerPodcast, #IdahoBourbon

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something bold and then go somewhere genuinely unsettling.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin’s behind the camera again, confirming his own existence one episode at a time — open 1792 Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon, bottled at its original 125 barrel entry proof, and dig into the folklore behind one of the most genuinely frightening video games ever made: Phasmophobia.

Phasmophobia’s 27 ghost types aren’t invented. Almost every single one is drawn from real-world paranormal tradition, folklore, and mythology stretching back thousands of years. The Poltergeist? There are real police affidavits and scientific instruments involved. The Banshee? Irish and Scottish families still report hearing the keening today. The Yurei? One of the most iconic ghost traditions in human history. The Jinn? Mentioned in the Quran. Justin and Jeff work through the ghosts one by one, match each to its real-world origin, and debate whether any of the documented cases hold up.

(Kevin is behind the camera. As always. We’re choosing to believe he is not himself a ghost.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE
1792 Full Proof | Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey | Limited Edition | Barton 1792 Distillery, Bardstown, KY
Named for the year Kentucky was admitted to the Union. The Full Proof expression is a limited edition that forgoes the typical chill filtration process — passing only through a plate and frame filter — and is bottled at its original 125 barrel entry proof. The result is a bourbon with maximum character, exactly as it came off the barrel.
Proof: 125 (62.5% ABV) | Non-chill filtered | Limited Edition
Tasting notes: Deep and smoky with a bold, full-bodied character. Sweet vanilla and caramel balance the smoke, building to a rich, warming finish. Bourbon insiders have long considered full proof expressions to offer the most authentic and distinguished flavour profile a distillery produces.
Learn more: 1792bourbon.com

WHAT WE COVER
• What Phasmophobia is and why it scares people who know it’s a game
• The Poltergeist — the Enfield case (police affidavit, the Warren investigation) and the Rosenheim case (calibrated instruments, physicists, no explanation)
• The Banshee — Irish and Scottish death omen folklore still reported today
• The Yurei — Japanese ghost tradition, the onryo, and the 1825 Yotsuya Kaidan
• The Jinn — pre-Islamic and Islamic supernatural tradition, mentioned in the Quran
• The Mare — the origin of the word ‘nightmare’ and the Old Hag sleep paralysis phenomenon
• The Goryo — how Japan’s government literally deified a ghost to stop natural disasters
• Every culture on Earth has these — what does that mean?
• 1792 Full Proof: barrel entry proof, non-chill filtered, and full tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #Phasmophobia, #GhostTypes, #Poltergeist, #Banshee, #Paranormal, #1792Bourbon, #FullProofBourbon, #BourbonPodcast, #GhostLore

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we pour something exceptional and then question everything, including whether we’re even in the right timeline.

This week, Justin, Jeff, and Kevin — Kevin is here, he’s behind the camera, he exists, we can confirm this — open Rabbit Hole Heigold High-Rye Double Malt Bourbon and go deep on one of the most mind-bending theories in modern physics: Quantum Immortality.

The idea: if the Many-Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics is correct, the universe branches at every quantum event. In every branch where you die, there’s a branch where you didn’t — and your consciousness can only ever find itself in the branch where it survived. Which means you are, subjectively, immortal. You’ve always been the survivor. You’ve never experienced a branch where you didn’t make it, because you couldn’t.

Justin takes it further. What if the 2012 Mayan calendar date really was a convergence point where countless timelines ended? What if CERN’s Large Hadron Collider created a catastrophic branch-point event in some timelines and we’re simply in the ones that survived? And what if your Mandela Effect memories — the Berenstain Bears, the Monopoly Man’s monocle, Sinbad’s genie movie — are real memories from the timelines you left behind? Jeff pushes back. Kevin operates the camera.

(Kevin is here. Behind the camera. He is real. This is the most we can say with certainty.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE
Rabbit Hole Heigold | High-Rye Double Malt Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Rabbit Hole Distillery, Louisville, KY
Named for Christian Heigold, a German immigrant stonemason whose craftsmanship left a lasting mark on Louisville, Kentucky. Just as Heigold carved his vision into stone, Rabbit Hole carved this bourbon from one of the most distinctive grain bills in Kentucky — using a culinary approach to grain selection that sets every Rabbit Hole expression apart.
Mash Bill: 70% corn, 25% malted rye, 5% malted barley | Proof: 95 (47.5% ABV)
Nose: Sweet toasted malt and warm baking spices. Palate: Silky butterscotch opening into bursts of bright citrus with a rich, full-bodied mouthfeel. Finish: A thrilling crescendo of pepper spice — long and bold.
Awards: Gold Medal — San Francisco World Spirits Competition 2024, Double Gold — New York World Spirits Competition 2024, named one of the 25 Best Bourbons of the 21st Century — Robb Report.
Learn more: rabbitholedistillery.com

WHAT WE COVER
• Schrödinger’s Cat and the Many-Worlds Interpretation explained simply
• Quantum Suicide: the thought experiment that led to Quantum Immortality
• Why your consciousness can only ever find itself in a timeline where it survived
• The 2012 Mayan calendar date as a multiverse convergence point — not a prediction, a probability cluster
• CERN and the Large Hadron Collider as a branch-point generator
• The Mandela Effect as cross-timeline memory bleed from timelines that ended
• The terrifying fine print: quantum immortality doesn’t promise a good life, just a persistent one
• Rabbit Hole Heigold: the culinary grain approach, the Christian Heigold story, and full tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends, #QuantumImmortality, #ManyWorlds, #MandelaEffect, #CERN, #MayanCalendar, #RabbitHoleDistillery, #HeigoldBourbon, #BourbonPodcast, #ConspiracyTheory

Welcome back to Bourbon Legends — where we open something great and then go somewhere strange.

This week, Justin and Jeff pour Bulleit Kentucky Straight Bourbon — the high-rye frontier whiskey that’s been turning heads since Augustus Bulleit first made it in 1830 — and dig into one of the most credible cryptid cases in American history: the Loveland Frogman.

A 4-foot bipedal frog-like creature with glowing orange eyes and an overwhelming putrid smell has been reported near the Little Miami River outside Loveland, Ohio since at least 1955. In 1972, two police officers filed independent reports on back-to-back nights describing the same creature on the same stretch of road. One of them fired a shot at it. It stepped calmly over a guardrail, maintained eye contact, and walked into the river. No blood trail was found. Then in April 2026, two Ohio state representatives introduced a bipartisan bill to make the Loveland Frogman the state’s official cryptid. Justin and Jeff break down 70 years of sightings, the dead dog detail, the wand that emits sparks, and whether this is the cryptid case that finally holds up.

(Kevin’s not here. The Frogman may or may not be involved.)

BOURBON OF THE EPISODE
Bulleit Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Bulleit Distilling Co. | Diageo
A true high-rye frontier bourbon with roots going back to 1830, when Augustus Bulleit first created the recipe in Louisville, Kentucky. Revived by his great-great-grandson Tom Bulleit in 1987. The high rye content — at 28% one of the highest in mainstream bourbon — gives Bulleit its distinctive spicy, bold character.
Mash Bill: 68% corn, 28% rye, 4% malted barley | Proof: 90 (45% ABV) | Aged minimum 6 years
Nose: Cinnamon and nutmeg spiced sandalwood, leather, corn, and vanilla. Palate: Bold and spicy — cinnamon, black pepper, and clove leading into caramel and vanilla with a medium-bodied mouthfeel. Finish: Warm, medium-long, with lingering spice, toasted oak, and a touch of dried fruit.
Learn more: bulleit.com

WHAT WE COVER
• The 1955 Branch Hill encounter: three creatures, a spark-emitting wand, and a smell of almonds and alfalfa
• The 1972 police sightings: Officer Shockey and Deputy Matthews on back-to-back nights, the gunshot, no blood trail
• The 2016 Pokémon Go sighting and dashcam footage
• The fire department chief who saw it from his car headlights
• Why the wand from 1955 breaks every conventional explanation
• The iguana theory — and its significant problems
• Ohio’s bipartisan bill to make it the official state cryptid
• Bulleit Bourbon: history, high-rye character, and tasting notes

SUBSCRIBE
New episodes every week. New bourbon. New legend. Hit subscribe so you never miss a pour.

#BourbonLegends #LovelandFrogman #Cryptid #OhioCryptid #Frogman #BulleitBourbon #BourbonPodcast #UrbanLegends #Cryptids #ConspiracyTheory