In August 1985, five members of the same family were found shot dead inside a farmhouse in rural Essex.

At first, investigators believed the deaths were the result of a murder-suicide carried out by Sheila Caffell. Within weeks, the investigation changed direction, and her adopted brother, Jeremy Bamber, was charged and later convicted of all five murders.

In this episode of What They Hide: Hidden Crimes in Plain Sight, we examine the White House Farm murders through a careful, fact-based retelling of events. We explore the early investigation, the evidence presented at trial, the competing narratives put before the jury, and the appeals and reviews that have kept the case in public debate for decades.

This is not a story about speculation.

It is a reminder that behind every contested case are lives that were lost, families permanently changed, and questions that continue to echo long after a verdict is reached.

We remember:

Nevill Bamber

June Bamber

Sheila Caffell

Nicholas Caffell

Daniel Caffell

Research for this episode was compiled using publicly available records and reporting, including:

• Court of Appeal Judgment (R v Bamber, 2002)
• Criminal Cases Review Commission case materials and summaries
• Contemporary reporting from BBC News, The Guardian, and The Independent
• Historical investigative timelines published by major UK news organisations
• Publicly documented trial and sentencing records

All information has been presented with care and respect for the victims and their families.

music by MUBERT

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.