What does it mean to be a confessional Lutheran—and why does it matter how you answer that question?

In this episode, hosts the Rev. Dr. Maurice Lee and the Rev. Dr. Nathan Yoder sit down with Dr. David Luy to unpack the ideas behind his lecture at the 2025 NALC Clergy Retreat. This is the first of two conversation episodes exploring what Luy calls confessions as "a way into riches"—and why how we hold our confessional identity shapes everything about our ministry, our preaching, and our life with God.

What you'll hear in this episode:

The conversation opens with the origins of the retreat theme itself—why the NALC seminary asked how the church's confessional character should be described, not just defended. From there, Luy introduces the central tension: between a confessionalism that is primarily negative (defined by what we're not) and one that is oriented toward the inexhaustible riches of the Christian faith.

Along the way, Maurice and Nathan draw out key themes from the lecture:

• The Peter/Lucy contrast from The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe—the warrior posture vs. the sense of wonder and adventure
• The dangers of a "keep it simple" approach to doctrine—how reducing the faith to manageable categories can paradoxically produce something thin and brittle
• Edmund Schlink's emphasis on the primacy of doxology—and how it shaped Luy's understanding of what the confessions are for
• Wittgenstein's phrase "going on in the same way"—and what it means to be faithful to the confessions without mere mimetic repetition
• The Nestorius/Chalcedon question: what binds us—the theological judgment, or the historical context in which it was made?
• Dietrich Bonhoeffer as an exemplar of confessional faithfulness that never merely sloganeers

The episode closes with a teaser for the next conversation: the "parable of the city" and what it looks like to navigate vast theological space with the confessions as a guide rather than a cage.

Resources mentioned:

• Edmund Schlink, Ecumenical Dogmatics (English translation of Ökumenische Dogmatik)
• C.S. Lewis, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe and The Last Battle
• Charles Porterfield Krauth (referenced in relation to confessional vows)
• Robert Jenson (referenced by Nathan on the use and abuse of slogans)
• The 2025 NALC Clergy Retreat

Cardigan & Collar is a podcast of the North American Lutheran Seminary, pursuing theological conversations for the enrichment of pastoral ministry.

🎧 Listen and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
🌐 Learn more about NALS: thenals.org