16-year-old White Mountain Apache teen Challistia Colelay was reported missing on October 16, 2025 and later found deceased near Whitewater, Arizona, on November 3. At the time of recording, authorities had not reported any arrests. Since then, the family has stated that a teen suspect is now in custody, though the Bureau of Indian Affairs has not publicly confirmed the arrest. Who is responsible and why are families still left waiting for the truth?

Sources:

https://www.fox10phoenix.com/news/challistia-colelay-arrest-made-white-mountain-apache-girls-death.amp

https://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona-breaking/2025/11/14/remains-teen-challistia-tia-colelay-found-whiteriver-arizona/87229219007/

https://www.azfamily.com/2025/11/14/feds-offer-5k-reward-after-teen-girl-found-dead-eastern-arizona/?outputType=amp

Support the show

Lakota Renville left home at 20, believing she was stepping into a new future. Two years later, in 2005, she was found in Independence, Missouri and nearly twenty years later, her case remains unsolved. One distinctive clue has been released, and investigators still believe someone recognizes it.

Sources:

https://fox4kc.com/news/still-no-answers-20-years-after-woman-found-stabbed-to-death-in-independence/amp/

https://lompocrecord.com/lakota-rae-renville/article_dd07e9c7-b1d2-50cb-91cc-1a605404ec1e.amp.html

https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/4bsfxt/the2005_unsolved_murder_of_lakota_renville/

https://www.kshb.com/news/local-news/investigations/mmip-series-i-team-focuses-on-2005-cold-case-murder-of-indigenous-woman-lakota-renville

https://defrostingcoldcases.com/lakota-rae-renville-1983-2005/

https://www.kshb.com/news/local-news/investigations/community-marks-18-years-since-lakota-renville-found-murdered-in-independence

https://www.kctv5.com/video/2023/05/24/relatives-search-justice-lakota-renville-more-than-17-years-after-her-body-was-discovered/?outputType=amp

Support the show

On a night meant for costumes and laughter, two Native teens vanished, years apart, in the same Minnesota town and neither has been seen since.

In this Halloween special, we remember 17-year-old Jeremy “Worm” Jourdain and 15-year-old Nevaeh Kingbird, who disappeared under hauntingly similar circumstances in Bemidji, Minnesota.

If you know anything, please come forward.

Jeremy Jourdain:

BIA MMU Tip Line — 1-833-560-2065

Nevaeh Kingbird:

Bemidji PD — 218-333-9111

CrimeStoppers MN — 1-800-222-TIPS

Sources:

Jeremy Jourdain | Indian Affairs

Jeremy Jourdain | International Missing Persons Wiki | Fandom

Jeremy 'Worm' Jourdain Went Missing On Halloween 2016 | Investigation Discovery

Minnesota teen Jeremy Jourdain still missing two years after disappearing from party on Halloween

Search continues for Nevaeh Kingbird 4 years after her disappearance - InForum | Fargo, Moorhead and West Fargo news, weather and sports

Nevaeh Kingbird's disappearance leads sister down new career path | kare11.com

The search continues for missing 15-year-old Nevaeh Kingbird in Bemidji, Minnesota

Search continues for missing Bemidji teens near anniversary of disappearances - The Bemidji Pioneer is your #1 source for news, weather, and sports around Bemidji and throughout Minnesota.

Support the show