Send us Fan Mail

This week, things are looking a little different around here because Terra has company. Shaq is stepping into the guest-host seat, and he’s bringing us one of the creepiest unsolved mysteries in true crime history: the Hinterkaifeck murders.

In 1922, a remote German farm became the center of a mystery that has haunted investigators for more than a century. Strange footprints. Unexplained noises. Someone—or something—lurking around the property. And then, a horrifying discovery that left an entire community searching for answers.

Who was watching the family before the crime? Why were there signs that someone may have remained on the farm afterward? And how the hell did the killer disappear without being caught?

Shaq is presenting the case, Terra is bringing the commentary, and together they're diving headfirst into one of history's most baffling unsolved mysteries.

Lock your doors, trust your gut, and grab your bestie… because this week, the vibes are VERY haunted.

Send us Fan Mail

In 2009, a horrific crash on the Taconic State Parkway left eight people dead and raised a question that still sparks debate today: how did Diane Schuler end up driving the wrong way down the highway with children in her vehicle?

The investigation painted a disturbing picture, but Diane’s family has continued to dispute key parts of the official account—and more than 15 years later, people are still arguing over what really happened that morning.

In this episode of Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re breaking down the timeline, the evidence, the investigation, the unanswered questions, and the theories that have kept this case in the true-crime conversation for years.

Because sometimes the most disturbing cases aren't about a mystery killer.

Sometimes they're about trying to understand how one morning went so catastrophically wrong.

Put your bestie on speaker, buckle up, and let’s get into it.

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when a wannabe filmmaker becomes a little too obsessed with the idea of being a fictional serial killer?

Mark Twitchell wanted to make movies. He wanted attention. And apparently, he wanted to channel a little too much of his inner Dexter Morgan. What started with online deception and a fascination with the macabre eventually turned into a very real murder investigation—and one of the strangest cases to come across the true crime table.

In Episode 5, we’re diving into the story of Mark Twitchell, the man dubbed the “Dexter Killer,” and how his obsession with fiction, fantasy, and playing the villain crossed a line that could never be uncrossed.

We’re talking fake identities, online dating, murder plots, a filmmaker with some seriously questionable ideas, and the moment investigators started realizing this wasn’t just another creepy internet story.

So grab your snacks, pull up a seat, and come hang out with your favorite creepy bestie—because this week, we’re asking the question:

How badly can someone misunderstand the difference between watching Dexter and actually trying to become him?

Like, subscribe, share, and hey… a 5-star review couldn’t hurt. 🖤

Send us Fan Mail

Last week, we walked through the chilling timeline, the haunting church surveillance footage, and the investigation that left more questions than answers.

Now it's time to dive into everything that came after.

In Part 2, we're taking a closer look at the people, the possible motives, and the theories that have kept the murder of Missy Bevers at the center of true crime conversations for years. From financial troubles and personal relationships to the names that have repeatedly surfaced online, we're separating confirmed facts from internet speculation.

Could this have been a targeted attack? Was someone trying to send a message? Or has the truth been hiding in plain sight all along?

We'll examine the evidence, discuss the most talked-about theories, and explore why this case remains one of the most frustrating unsolved murders in recent history.

So grab your emotional support snack, light one if that's your thing, and let's dive into a case where everybody had questions... but nobody had answers.

Send us Fan Mail

What was supposed to be an early morning fitness class turned into one of the most baffling unsolved murders in true crime history.

In Part 1 of the Missy Bevers case, we're breaking down the timeline leading up to that April morning in Midlothian, Texas, when fitness instructor Missy Bevers arrived at Creekside Church of Christ... and never made it home.

We'll dive into the chilling surveillance footage of a mysterious figure dressed in police tactical gear wandering the halls of the church nearly 30 minutes before the murder, casually opening doors, smashing windows, and acting like they had nowhere else to be. Was it a calculated killer? A burglary gone horribly wrong? Or something even stranger?

We'll walk through the events leading up to the crime, examine the infamous footage that has left investigators and internet sleuths scratching their heads for years, and discuss why this case continues to haunt the true crime community.

So grab your emotional support snack, light one if that's your thing, and settle in... because this mystery only gets weirder from here.

Send us Fan Mail

Nine-year-old Katie Beers should've been worried about homework, cartoons, and whether her Tamagotchi was still alive, not surviving one of the most horrifying kidnappings in modern history.

When Katie vanished on New Year's Day in 1992, the entire country was glued to the search. Seventeen days later, the truth came crawling out of the ground... literally.

This week, we're talking about the hidden underground bunker where Katie was held captive, the predator who thought he was smarter than everyone else, and the long list of adults who failed this little girl long before she ever disappeared. Spoiler alert: I have some opinions. And by "some," I mean enough side quests and unhinged commentary to make you yell at your speakers right along with me.

So grab your emotional support snack, spark up if you're part of the 420 crew, and settle in, accomplices. Because this case is equal parts unbelievable, infuriating, and proof that sometimes the real monsters aren't hiding in the dark—they're sitting right at the family barbecue.

Send us Fan Mail

This season, we're kicking things off with one of the most infamous serial killers in American history: BTK—the self-proclaimed "Bind, Torture, Kill" murderer whose desperate need for attention ended up being his own downfall.

In this episode, Terra dives into the timeline of Dennis Rader's reign of terror, the heartbreaking impact on his victims and their families, the years-long investigation, and the unbelievable ego that ultimately got him caught. Because if there were ever a serial killer who desperately wanted a fan club, it was this clown.

We'll break down the case, call out the ridiculousness, and remind everyone why the real story is about the innocent lives he stole—not the nickname he gave himself.

So grab your favorite snack, settle in, and let's unpack one of true crime's most infuriating cases—with a little dark humor aimed exactly where it belongs.

Listener discretion is advised. This episode discusses murder and violence and may not be suitable for all audiences.

Send us Fan Mail

Just a little announcement with a side of crime of course!

We here at TTMV wish you all a safe and happy holiday season. Stay tuned for Season 4 coming after the new year!