This isn't a review, this is a decision…

PART 1 – The Nutshell – If you haven’t seen it

A spoiler-free breakdown of The Prestige, but more importantly, a breakdown of whether this is your kind of movie and if it's worth your time.

An exploration of what makes this episode different: the tension in the room, the immediate disagreement, and the feeling that this film demands more from you than most.

A look at the type of movie night this creates, not passive viewing, not background noise, but something that requires attention and rewards it.

By the end of Part 1, you’ll know whether this is a film you should queue up… and whether you’re ready for it.

PART 2 – The Unboxing – If you’ve seen it

What Did You Miss?

We dig into:

The subtle details that completely reframe your interpretation.

The element that divided us most in the studio.

Whether emotional connection matters more than technical brilliance.

And the one question that turned into a genuine back-and-forth.

This isn’t surface-level praise. It’s a proper discussion about what makes something great and what just makes it clever.

You’ll hear:

The moment Darren changed his stance mid-discussion

Marc pushing back hard on one specific point

Paul trying to keep the peace… and then choosing a side

It’s one of our most balanced — and most split — debates.

Paul’s Facts of the Day

A tightly packed set of production insights and behind-the-scenes details, including:

How Christopher Nolan positioned this film within his career.

Casting decisions that shaped the tone, including Christian Bale and Hugh Jackman.

And the context that explains why this film still sparks discussion nearly two decades later.

Hate It or Rate It?

This is where it gets interesting.

The scores are close… but the reasoning couldn’t be more different.

Finally we reveal where it lands in the Legend League and the Listener League.

Does this long-awaited Listener Choice live up to expectation?

PART 3 – Listener Lounge

Joe Lamb’s year-long campaign finally pays off.

We read out your responses to last week’s Question of the Week and share a real-life story that genuinely felt cinematic — one that Marc forgot to tell before and finally delivers here.

Question of the Week

Best movie rivalries?

On-screen. Off-screen. Even your own real-life ones.

We want your stories.

Listen Now

https://2ly.link/24tPI⁠

View the Listener League

See how listeners rated the movies they chose

https://linkly.link/2Bi9l⁠

View the Legend League

Every movie we’ve featured and rated on the podcast

https://linkly.link/2Bfcv⁠

Join the conversation

Voice message

https://linkly.link/2FuSQ⁠

Email

hello@moviesinanutshell.com

Socials

Website

https://www.moviesinanutshell.com⁠

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/moviesinanut⁠

Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/moviesinanut⁠

Hosts

Marc Farquhar

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/marcfarquhar⁠

Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/themarcfarquhar⁠

Darren Horne

LinkedIn

https://www.linkedin.com/in/thedarrenhorne⁠

Paul Day

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/pauldaylive23⁠

Recorded at

Sunbeams Studios

https://www.thestudioatsunbeams.co.uk⁠

Part of Annie Mawson’s Sunbeams Music...