Send us Fan Mail

She came forward on her own. Saw the news coverage, recognized what had happened to her, and made the call. What happened next is what this episode is about.

Case 2023-2700 is the second victim's case. A graduating senior at Rocky River High School. Michael Bernhardt was her SRO during her senior year. When BCI investigators asked him about his Snapchat username, he gave them ponch6514. The warrant return for this case documents a different account called Bernie that he never mentioned. In that same interview, he acknowledged managing that account specifically so his wife would not find out. When asked to describe what was happening between him and an enrolled student, he said they were romantically linked.

He also told her she was almost an adult.

He had been a member of ICAC. His entire training was built around identifying adults who exploit the apparent consent of young people. He knew what the law said. ORC Section 2907.03(7) makes sexual conduct between a school authority figure and an enrolled student sexual battery regardless of age. That statute does not say unless she is almost 18.

On January 10, 2024, BCI Chief Legal Counsel Zahid Siddiqi directed Special Agent Heather Karl not to pursue the second victim's case independently, citing a prior legal determination by special prosecutor Michael Maloney. The woman who drove to Maloney's office with a written statement was turned away by the secretary. Her statement was never taken. Maloney still concluded insufficient grounds for criminal charges.

I asked everyone in that decision chain to explain the outcome on the record. Nobody answered the question I asked.

This episode also covers the Westlake Library, corroborated by Cellebrite analysis and location tracking. The guilt Bernhardt carried for years and what he spent it on. And what his mother said when she first heard the news.

www.theinfamousexchief.com

Support the show

Visit: https://www.liinks.co/the.infamous.exchief

Send us Fan Mail

Garrettsville PD billed me $225 for body camera footage. Their own
CAD records show approximately 57 minutes of combined on-scene time
across both incidents. Ohio Revised Code 149.43(B)(1) caps body
camera fees at $75 per hour of video produced — not per hour of
labor, not per hour of staff time. Per hour of video produced. At
that rate, 57 minutes of footage has a maximum lawful fee of about
$71.25. I was charged $225.

Before anything else: the officers who worked these calls did their
jobs right. A noise complaint resolved with a warning. A welfare
check that got someone to a hospital. No problem with any of that.
This is a records and transparency question only.

I paid the $225 anyway — I'm not letting a fee dispute be the reason
this footage sits in a drawer. I filed two challenge letters on July
19 contesting the exemption basis and the rate calculation. On July
21 I sent a formal inquiry to the Ohio Attorney General's Sunshine
Laws unit asking one question: does $75 per hour mean per hour of
footage length or per hour of labor? No Ohio court has answered that
yet. This law took effect April 2025.

The ACLU of Ohio challenged an identical fee in the Village of
Brewster on the same grounds. NBC4 Columbus reported in October 2025
that legal experts identified this as a statewide misreading of the
statute. The footage is paid for. The challenges are active. The AG
has been notified.

When this gets answered, you'll see it here first.

PRR filed under Ohio Revised Code 149.43.

Pro-Police. Not Pro-Corruption.
Be loud. Be heard. Shake the system until the truth falls out.

Support the show

Visit: https://www.liinks.co/the.infamous.exchief

Send us Fan Mail

Episode 3 of The Worst-Kept Secret, an ongoing investigation into Rocky River Police Department SRO Michael Bernhardt, covers what the department knew, when they knew it, and what everyone around Bernhardt did or failed to do with that information.

Bernhardt's second wife, a 30-year special education coordinator at Rocky River High School, describes going to the superintendent in person to report her husband. The official administrative leave letter signed by Chief Lichtman described her as an anonymous faculty member. She then drove to special prosecutor Michael Maloney's law office in Westlake with a written statement. His secretary could not accept it. She called back multiple times over the following weeks. The investigation was filed without her formal account.

Bernhardt's first wife, a police officer with 19 years at Fairview Park PD, sat down with BCI agents in July 2024 and described what she believes the department knew going back over 20 years. She believes Chief Lichtman knew something was happening at the library overtime shifts where Bernhardt first encountered the first victim. Lichtman denies any knowledge prior to 2023. Both accounts are on the record.

An informal determination made within the department in the early 2000s, that Bernhardt had committed no crime due to a lack of physical contact, was legally wrong under ORC 2907.03(A)(7). No one with actual legal authority ever reviewed it. Bernhardt remained the Rocky River SRO for 20 more years.

Bernhardt and Lichtman both served on the internet crimes against children task force. Bernhardt's role was to pose online and engage with predators. His first wife's assessment, stated plainly to BCI agents in July 2024: little did we know he was one.

The special prosecutor's file went to the city with an open question about seizing Bernhardt's phone for forensic analysis. That question appears to have never been formally answered. The union was denied the full investigative file. The public was told no responsive records existed.

On July 8, 2026, a six-part public records request was filed to law director Michael O'Shea's office. This series follows it.

Full series: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDpI0ydpXyzWIPEpdUAM4WZOFT6XVBjkM

www.theinfamousexchief.com

Support the show

Visit: https://www.liinks.co/the.infamous.exchief