Can machines become conscious? And if they do, what kind of moral relationship should we have with them?

In this second installment on the AI Alignment Problem, Justin and Nick delve into the philosophy, neuroscience, and mysticism surrounding machine consciousness. They explore whether AI systems could possess a subjective inner life—and if so, whether alignment should be reimagined as moral resonance instead of mere goal matching. Along the way, they discuss how mindfulness, memory, embodiment, and suffering shape our understanding of what it means to be sentient—and how we might recognize or construct such capacities in artificial systems.

You’ll leave this episode with a deeper understanding of consciousness—from the perspective of both humans and machines—and what it might mean to extend moral standing to synthetic minds.

• What is consciousness and how do we define it?
• Can artificial systems host genuine subjective experience?
• The neuroscience and computational theories of consciousness
• The “Hard Problem” and the possibility of virtualizing consciousness
• Ethical standing of sentient AI systems
• Machine consciousness and Buddhist moral development
• The role of embodiment, memory, and collective cognition in consciousness
• Panpsychism, fungal networks, and plant sentience
• AI as a mirror to human moral behavior

• Meaning in the Multiverse – Justin Harnish
• A framework for emergent meaning and the evolution of consciousness—central to understanding alignment as co-development.
• Waking Up – Sam Harris
• Neuroscience, meditation, and the illusion of self.
• Feeling and Knowing – Antonio Damasio
• Emotion, embodiment, and consciousness—critical for thinking about AI without a body.
• Mindfulness – Joseph Goldstein
• Practical tools for present-moment ethics and self-awareness.
• Reality+ – David J. Chalmers
• Virtual realism and consciousness in simulation.
• The Case Against Reality – Donald Hoffman
• Conscious agents and perceptual interface theory.
• On Having No Head – Douglas Harding
• A first-person meditation on the illusion of self.
• I Am a Strange Loop – Douglas Hofstadter
• Recursion, identity, and consciousness emergence.

• The Feeling of Life Itself – Christof Koch
• Integrated Information Theory and the measure of consciousness.
• Moral Tribes – Joshua Greene
• Dual-process moral reasoning, tribalism, and AI ethics.
• The Ethical Algorithm – Michael Kearns & Aaron Roth
• Engineering ethics into AI decision-making.
• The Nature of Consciousness – Alan Watts (Waking Up App)
• “You are it”: Consciousness as the universe reflecting on itself.
• The Soul of an Octopus – Sy Montgomery
• Comparative consciousness in non-human animals and implications for synthetic minds.

• Thomas Nagel – “What is it like to be a bat?”
• David Chalmers – The Hard Problem of Consciousness, Reality+
• Max Tegmark – Life 3.0, consciousness as information processing
• Giulio Tononi – Integrated Information

In this episode, Justin and Nick dive into The Alignment Problem—one of the most pressing challenges in AI development. Can we ensure that AI systems align with human values and intentions? What happens when AI behavior diverges from what we expect or desire?

Drawing on real-world examples, academic research, and philosophical thought experiments, they explore the risks and opportunities AI presents. From misaligned AI causing unintended consequences to the broader existential question of intelligence in the universe, this conversation tackles the complexity of AI ethics, governance, and emergent behavior.

They also discuss historical perspectives on automation, regulatory concerns, and the possible future of AI—whether it leads to existential risk or a utopian technological renaissance.

Understanding the AI Alignment Problem – Why AI alignment matters and its real-world implications.

Why Not Just ‘Pull the Plug’ on AI? – A philosophical and practical discussion.

Emergent AI & Unpredictability – How AI learns in ways we can’t always foresee.

Historical Parallels – Lessons from past industrial and technological revolutions.

The Great Filter & The Fermi Paradox – Could AI be part of humanity’s existential challenge?

The Ethics of AI Decision-Making – The real-world trolley problem and AI’s moral choices.

Can AI Ever Be Truly ‘Aligned’ with Humans? – Challenges of defining and enforcing values.

Industry & Regulation – How governments and businesses are handling AI risks.

What Happens When AI Becomes Conscious? – A preview of the next episode’s deep dive.

The Alignment Problem – Brian Christian

Human Compatible – Stuart Russell

Superintelligence – Nick Bostrom

The Second Machine Age – Erik Brynjolfsson & Andrew McAfee

The End of Work – Jeremy Rifkin

The Demon in the Machine – Paul Davies

Anarchy, State, and Utopia – Robert Nozick

• Clarifying AI Alignment – Paul Christiano
• The AI Alignment Problem in Context – Raphaël Millière
• 
  

1. AI alignment is crucial but deeply complex—defining human values is harder than it seems.
2. AI could be an existential risk or the key to ending scarcity and expanding humanity’s potential.
3. Conscious AI might be necessary for true alignment, but we don’t fully understand consciousness.
4. Industry and government must work together to create effective AI governance frameworks.
5. We may be at a pivotal moment in history—what we do next could define our species’ future.

🔹 Nick’s Pick: Cursor – An AI-powered coding assistant that enhances development workflows.

🔹 Justin’s Pick: Leveraging Enterprise AI – Make use of...

The Emergent AI Podcast with Justin Harnish & Nick Baguley

Episode Summary:

Today on The Emergent AI Podcast, Justin and Nick explore the future of human-AI collaboration and what it means to live and work alongside dynamic, reasoning AI systems. From agentic AI workflows in healthcare, finance, and creativity, to the philosophical and existential questions surrounding AI’s role in society, this episode dives deep into how humans and AI can thrive together in a rapidly evolving landscape.

We tackle the fears of job displacement, the promise of eliminating drudgery, and the bold vision of achieving human flourishing through AI augmentation — not replacement. And we tee up the critical conversation for next time: alignment between human well-being and AI goals.

Books:

• The Master Algorithm – Pedro Domingos
• Superintelligence – Nick Bostrom
• Human Compatible – Stuart Russell
• The Alignment Problem – Brian Christian
• The Future of Work – Darrell West
• AI 2041 – Kai-Fu Lee & Chen Qiufan
• Competing in the Age of AI – Marco Iansiti & Karim Lakhani
• Reprogramming the American Dream – Kevin Scott

Articles & Papers:

• The Role of AI in Augmenting Human Capabilities – MIT Tech Review
• The Rise of Agentic AI – Stanford AI Lab
• AI and the Future of Decision Making – McKinsey Report

• Agentic AI Workflows: How modern AI models, organized into multi-agent “crews,” reason, act, and augment human capabilities in fields like healthcare, finance, and creative arts.
• Breaking Down Fears: Is AI replacing humans? Or freeing us from drudgery so we can focus on creativity, leadership, and strategy.
• Real-World Examples:
• AI-assisted diagnostics in medicine
• Fraud detection in finance
• AI co-authors in creative fields

• The Existential Questions
• What happens when AI develops its own goals?
• How do human values and AI objectives align (or diverge)?
• Can we ensure AI enhances, rather than harms, human flourishing?

• Human-AI Symbiosis is not about opposition; it’s about fractal augmentation — a shared space where human goals and machine goals co-evolve
• The evolution from simple automation to complex, reasoning agents that manage workflows and even other agents.
• Emergence of AI’s reasoning capabilities: from curve-fitting language models to goal-oriented reasoning engines.
• The future of work: abundance through automation vs. existential economic risks.
• Aligning AI goals with human survival and well-being as the defining challenge of our time.

Teaser for Episode 4:

“The Alignment Problem: How Do We Align Superintelligent AI with Human Goals?”

Join us as we dive into philosophy, policy, technology, and new approaches to guide the future of AI — and humanity.

We want to hear your thoughts on the future of Human-AI collaboration!

Justin’s Homepage - https://justinaharnish.com

Justin’s Substack - https://ordinaryilluminated.substack.com

Justin’s LinkedIn -