The Cleveland Torso Murders: The Art of Looking Busy

Between 1934 and 1938, bodies began appearing across Cleveland—dismembered, decapitated, and left in public places to be found. The violence wasn’t subtle. The patterns weren’t hidden. And yet, the case collapsed under its own chaos.

In this episode of Hot Mess Murder Club, Kat and Holly break down the Cleveland Torso Murders—also known as the Mad Butcher of Kingsbury Run—and expose how nonstop police activity replaced actual investigative strategy. Victims were reduced to labels instead of names. Evidence was fragmented across precincts. Patterns were documented but never connected. And political pressure turned panic into policy.

From unidentified victims like the Tattooed Man and the Lady of the Lake, to the arrival of Eliot Ness and his headline-driven “solutions,” this case shows how an investigation can look busy, burn neighborhoods, and still go absolutely nowhere.

This isn’t a mystery about a brilliant killer.
It’s a case study in what happens when no one is required to prove they’re doing their job.

🔥 Why this case is a Hot Mess:
Victims were dehumanized.
Patterns were ignored.
Evidence was scattered.
Politics replaced accountability.
And failure became routine.

New episodes drop every Monday.
The plot only thickens from here. See you there!

#TrueCrime
#TrueCrimePodcast
#UnsolvedMurders
#SerialKillerCases
#ColdCases
#CrimeHistory