Send us Fan Mail

Nonprofit donor segmentation strategy may matter far more than most fundraising teams realize. New donor behavior research reveals that geography, household income, gender, trust, and communication preferences can dramatically change what motivates someone to give!

Mary Crogan, Vice President of Brand Marketing at Bloomerang, returns with a deeper look at Bloomerang's ‘Giving Signals’ research with The Harris Poll. The original study surveyed more than 1,000 donors and several hundred fundraisers, then examined donor responses across demographic groups rather than treating supporters as one giant audience. The result challenges one of fundraising's most persistent habits.

“There’s no such thing as the donor,” Mary says. “And the data proves that.”

Consider geography. Only 45% of Midwest respondents expected to give more, compared with 62% in the West. Midwest donors were also considerably less responsive to identity and belonging language, suggesting that messages emphasizing concrete needs, transparency, and measurable outcomes may perform better with that audience.Trust creates another major business implication. The West registered 86% trust in nonprofits' effective use of funds, while 62% expected to increase giving. As Mary puts it, “You need to treat transparency as a fundraising activity, not just a compliance moment.”

The data also challenges assumptions about major gift messaging. Among households earning $150,000+, 41% looked to third-party ratings compared with 29% overall. These high-capacity donors behaved more like evidence-driven buyers, responding to ratings, audited outcomes, measured impact, and proof—not simply another moving story.

And donor trust does not develop identically. Women reported stronger responses to transparency, matching gifts, and proof of gift impact—with 93% citing information about their gift's impact—while men showed greater responsiveness to peer recommendations and preferred communication channels.

The operational takeaway: segment, survey, test, measure, and adjust before assuming one appeal speaks to everyone.

Key Takeaways:

Build fundraising segments around meaningful donor differences instead of relying on one universal appeal.

Treat transparency and closed-loop impact reporting as revenue-building activities.

Test concrete outcome messaging versus belonging-oriented messaging by geography.

Give high-capacity donors evidence: ratings, audited results, ROI, and measurable impact.

Use peer and ambassador voices where personal endorsement strengthens trust.

Survey your own donor base before turning national demographic patterns into fundraising assumptions.

00:00:00 — Why There’s No Such Thing As “The Donor”
00:01:46 — How Bloomerang Studies Donor Behavior
00:04:24 — What 1,000+ Donors Told Researchers
00:05:47 — Why Midwest Fundraising Messaging Is Different
00:09:48 — Trust Sits Upstream Of The Ask
00:12:16 — Income Changes What Motivates Donors
00:13:27 — The Ethical Edge Of Urgency Messaging
00:14:34 — The Problem With One-Size-Fits-All Appeals
00:16:31 — What High-Capacity Donors Actually Want
00:19:30 — Men, Women And Different Paths To Trust
00:23:10 — Turning Donors Into Trusted Ambassadors
00:25:15 — Survey Your Own Donor Community
00:27:02 — Segment And Test Before Your Next Appeal

#NonprofitFundraising #DonorEngagement #TheNonprofitShow

Find us Live daily on YouTube!

Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!

Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show

Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT

Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: HelpDesk@AmericanNonprofitAcademy.com
Visit us on the web:The Nonprofit Show