On this episode of So, You Like Horror?, we break down Midnight Mass, the slow-burning Netflix series from Mike Flanagan that challenges what horror can be. Joined by returning co-host Upnorth Scott, we explore how the show moves beyond traditional scares to examine faith, guilt, addiction, and the fear of death.

We discuss the role of Crockett Island as an isolated community shaped by belief, Riley Flynn’s struggle with trauma and loss of faith, and the contrast between doubt and certainty through characters like Bev Keane. We also take a closer look at Father Paul and how charisma and conviction can blur the line between faith and fanaticism.

The conversation dives into the show’s pacing, and how it builds tension through stillness rather than action. We break down the finale, its themes of accountability and acceptance, and how Midnight Mass compares to The Haunting of Hill House.

At its core, this episode examines how belief shapes identity, how stories influence truth, and why this series continues to stand out in modern horror television.

Thank you, everyone, for your support. If you have any questions or concerns, feel free to reach out on Instagram at ⁠⁠⁠@so_you_like_horror⁠⁠⁠ or email us directly at soyoulikehorror@gmail.com. We're open to all conversations, suggestions, topics, and criticisms.