What happens when a local historian decides to try something completely different? You get a spine-chilling true crime story from 1874 Snohomish—complete with dramatic narration, sound effects, and a murder that shocked the territory.
In this special episode, Trent sits down with Taylor Russell of Snohomish Walks to discuss the making of her first-ever true crime podcast episode. Then, you'll hear the full dramatic production of "The Seybert Tragedy"—a story of violence, survival, and justice in pioneer Washington that Taylor unearthed during years of cemetery research.
Behind-the-Scenes Highlights:
- [00:38] Why Taylor finally said "yes" to trying podcast format after years of hints from Trent
- [02:38] The perfect storm: Fall spookiness + finished research + curiosity = podcast experiment
- [04:37] From cemetery research to 300+ life stories: How Taylor's book Lost and Forgotten became a goldmine of podcast material
- [08:13] The creative process: Adapting 1980s "penny dreadful" style pamphlets into modern true crime format
- [10:35] Recording revelations: Why standing (not sitting) made all the difference for dramatic delivery
- [12:36] Post-production magic: Adding 20+ sound effects and finding the right pacing for maximum spookiness
Then, the main event at [17:23]: The complete true crime episode—The Seybert Tragedy
The Story: February 23, 1874. A blood-soaked cabin on the Snohomish River. A 16-year-old boy with an axe. A father with a dark reputation. What sounds like a simple murder case becomes a gripping exploration of domestic violence, mental health, and frontier justice.
Taylor's take: "What makes a really good crime drama is that it has a good balance of elements... It makes your heart and soul decide where you stand on this issue."
This isn't your typical true crime podcast—it's hyper-local history told with national-level production quality. It's proof that the most compelling stories aren't always happening somewhere else. Sometimes they're buried right in your own backyard.
Perfect for: True crime fans, local history buffs, aspiring podcasters curious about dramatic storytelling, and anyone who wants to hear what's possible when you step outside your comfort zone.
Content warning: This episode contains descriptions of domestic violence, child abuse, and murder.
Ready to experience Snohomish history like never before? 🎙️🔪
Story from: Taylor Russell
Produced and Edited by: Trent DeVerter
Intro Music: https://pixabay.com/music/upbeat-have-fun-382760/