Send us a text

Sun beats on Baker Street, the paper is dull, and then a small box arrives in Croydon filled with rough salt and two freshly severed ears. That jolt pulls us from a lazy August into one of the most unsettling puzzles we’ve ever worked through: a message posted from Belfast, a name misaddressed by a single initial, and ordinary details that refuse to stay ordinary. Coffee in the wrapping, tar in the twine, a sailor’s knot tied neat—each clue shifts the light until the picture sharpens into something far darker than a “student prank.”

We walk into Miss Susan Cushing’s tidy front room and find the case belongs to family as much as to crime. Sarah and Mary stand beside Susan in a portrait, and Holmes notices something uncanny: the female ear in the box matches the living sister’s ear in form. That single observation reframes the entire mystery. The parcel, it seems, was meant for Sarah, the sister with a Liverpool past and a quarrel that soured into silence. From there, a maritime trail emerges—pierced ears, dock salt, and a route that touches Belfast—pointing us toward Jim Browner, a steward on the May Day, and a story steeped in jealousy and drink.

When Lestrade arrests Browner at the Thames, the confession lands like iron. He speaks of love turned poison by Sarah’s meddling, of Alec Fairbairn’s charm, and of a mind that snapped when he spotted his wife laughing beside another man. He follows them to New Brighton, rows into a haze, and commits a double murder on the water. The ears, salted and boxed, become the cruel proof he addresses to the sister he blames. We end not in triumph but with Holmes’s quiet question: what purpose does this circle of misery serve, and can reason do more than draw the map after the storm has passed?

If you enjoy thoughtful, clue-rich storytelling that balances razor-sharp deduction with human weight, subscribe, share this episode with a friend, and leave us a review. Tell us which detail turned the case for you and what you think justice looks like here.

Support the show

Send us a text

A man lies dead by a quiet pool, a son stands accused, and the village is certain the case is closed. We step onto the platform with a telegram in hand and a question in mind: what if the obvious story is the wrong one? From the first “cooee” echo to the last whisper of “a rat,” we track how tiny details can overturn a perfect narrative.

We walk you through Holmes’s chain of reasoning as he reads the ground like a book: square-toed prints that come and go, a right-sided limp, the tell-tale ash of an Indian cigar smoked through a holder, and a stone that speaks louder than a gun butt. A map of Victoria turns a dying clue into a name—Ballarat—and a colonial past reaches into an English meadow. The investigation widens into motive and consequence: old crimes in the goldfields, decades of blackmail, and a hard choice set before a father who would do anything to shield his daughter.

What follows is part detection, part moral reckoning. We explore how circumstantial evidence seduces juries, why last words matter, and when mercy must temper truth. Lestrade’s certainty meets Holmes’s method, Miss Turner’s courage meets James McCarthy’s silence, and a confession arrives not as victory but as the end of a long penance. By the close, a life is saved, a secret is kept, and the balance between justice and compassion feels fragile and human.

f you relish classic detective work—footprint analysis, weapon inference, tobacco ash taxonomy—woven with big questions about law and conscience, this story will stay with you. Listen, share your favourite clue, and tell us: at what moment did you doubt the “obvious” culprit? Subscribe, leave a review, and pass it on to a friend who loves a twist driven by the smallest trace.

Support the show

Send us a text

A letter arrives with a single electrifying word—vampires—and the trail leads us to a crumbling Sussex farmhouse where fear thrives in the gaps between what we see and what we think we see. We step through heavy oak doors, past Tudor chimneys and South American weapons, into a home split between legend and reason: a baby with a bright red wound, a mother shunned as monstrous, and a father unravelled by doubt.

We walk carefully with Holmes as he strips away the theatre of superstition and reads what the room itself is saying. A spaniel’s sudden paralysis months earlier becomes a clue, not a coincidence. A tiny quiver and bird bow whisper about poisons that act faster than grief. The “bite” on the child’s neck reshapes into a desperate, ingenious act to draw venom, while silence hardens into a shield built to protect a husband from a truth he is not ready to bear. The heart of the mystery lies in the reflection of a son’s gaze: a flash of envy and wounded love that turns devotion into harm. It’s a case study in how jealousy can hide in the gentlest pose, and how a mother can be both accused and heroic at once.

Across the hour, we explore how evidence beats folklore, why context matters more than spectacle, and how family dynamics can warp even the best intentions. You’ll hear the moment deduction snaps into place, the tender and painful confrontation that follows, and a humane resolution that chooses repair over ruin. If you’re here for sharp clues, emotional stakes, and a reminder that the scariest monsters are often misunderstood motives, you’re in the right story.

If this mystery moved you or made you rethink a classic, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a quick review—what clue clinched it for you?

Support the show