Shemot 19 presents an apparent contradiction: the people are strictly forbidden from ascending Har Sinai or touching it, yet immediately afterward they are told that when the shofar sounds, they shall ascend the mountain. Classical commentators attempt to resolve this by either relocating the ascent to a later, unrecorded shofar blast (Saadia, Rashi, Ibn Ezra) or by reading the verse to mean that ascent is only permitted after the shofar stops (Rashbam, Bekhor Shor). Both approaches face significant textual and linguistic challenges. Professor Jonathan Grossman instead argues that the verse means exactly what it says: the long shofar blast during Maamad Har Sinai was intended as God’s invitation for the entire nation to ascend the mountain and experience direct revelation. Drawing on parallels to the shofar at Yericho—where the blast signals divine arrival and human approach—Grossman shows that the Torah uses a consistent narrative pattern in which the shofar marks the moment when sacred space becomes accessible.

Moshe’s retrospective account in Devarim supports this radical reading: the people were meant to ascend, but fear prevented them. Rather than accepting God’s invitation to meet the divine “face to face,” they recoiled from the overwhelming manifestation of fire, sound, and smoke, requesting that Moshe serve as intermediary. This shift had lasting spiritual consequences, perhaps even paving the way for the Golden Calf by depriving the people of the direct encounter meant to anchor their faith. The chapter thus becomes a profound meditation on the tension between divine desire for closeness and human fear of the transcendent—the tragedy of a relationship that could have been immediate, but became mediated instead.