The Grabber is back, and we've got the full, spoiler-heavy review for The Black Phone 2!

Scott Derrickson and Blumhouse delivered a stunning, highly-rated follow-up that had us arguing the entire episode. On one hand, this film is a near-perfect blueprint for a horror sequel—it takes the story to bold, ambitious, and terrifying new places with spectacular performances from Ethan Hawke and Madeleine McGraw. We truly loved it and scored it high!

But here’s the rub: did the story of Finney and The Grabber truly need a continuation? We dive deep into whether Black Phone 2's expanded supernatural lore and return of the iconic villain ultimately detracts from the chilling, contained ending of the first movie.

In this episode, we discuss:

• Our high score and why it works as a standalone horror film.
• How the sequel effectively tackles trauma and the supernatural element.
• The debate: Does a great, unnecessary sequel cheapen the original's legacy?
• Ethan Hawke's terrifying return as The Grabber.

#TheBlackPhone2 #BlackPhone2Review #HorrorSequel #EthanHawke #TheGrabber #Blumhouse #MovieReviewPodcast #ScottDerrickson #HorrorPodcast #FilmDebate

Get ready to pick up the phone! In this episode, we dive deep into Scott Derrickson's chilling supernatural thriller, The Black Phone, and we absolutely loved it! Join us as we praise Ethan Hawke's terrifying turn as "The Grabber" and celebrate the breakout performances from young stars Mason Thames (Finney) and Madeleine McGraw (Gwen). We break down the '70s setting, the incredible tension, the emotional themes of survival and empowerment, and why this Joe Hill adaptation is one of the best horror movies of the year. If you're looking for a scary, smart, and deeply satisfying film, you need to hear our glowing review! #theblackphone #thegrabber #ethanhawke #scottderrickson #moviereview

The critics slammed it, but we loved it. Our HIM movie review tackles the Jordan Peele-produced sports horror that has everyone talking. Was this a flawed genre-bender or a misunderstood masterpiece? We argue that HIM isn't a conventional horror movie, but a brilliant, surreal takedown of sports culture and the brutal cost of achieving GOAT status. Join us as we break down the shocking ending, Marlon Wayans' incredible performance, the hidden symbolism, and why the mainstream reviews completely missed the point of the film's challenging style. #filmcritic #moviereview #him #marlonwayans #movie #horror

We dive into the final chapter of the Warrens' story! Our The Conjuring: Last Rites review is here. The film delivers some genuinely terrifying scares. Did the story stick the landing? Listen as we dissect the jump scares, the demons, and the Conjuring 4 plot holes #conjuring #moviereview #filmcritic #horror #haunting

Ray Mendoza and Alex Garland deliver an absolute masterclass! Our Warfare movie review breaks down why this intense, Iraq War film is being hailed as the most authentic depiction of modern combat to date. We discuss the claustrophobic sound design, the real-time narrative, and the phenomenal ensemble cast (including Will Poulter and Joseph Quinn). If you want a deep dive into the brutal realism and technical brilliance of Warfare (2025), listen now!

#warfare #moviereview #filmcritic #movie

Was the new Zach Cregger film a letdown? We think so! Join us for our honest review of the Weapons movie (2025) where we discuss why the mystery fell flat, the plot twists were confusing, and the best parts didn't make any sense. #Weapons #filmcritic #moviereview #horror #movie

It's not just a horror film—it's a cinematic event! Join us for our glowing review of Sinners (2025), the period epic blending vampires, music, and social commentary. We break down Michael B. Jordan's dual performance, Ryan Coogler's visionary direction, and why this movie earned an exceptional rating. #sinners #michaelbjordan #ryancoogler #moviereview #filmcritic

Does the Man of Steel finally have a masterpiece? We review Superman (2025) and couldn't be happier with this incredible start to the new DC Universe. We explain why this film is a massive success, the standout performances, and our thoughts on James Gunn's start for the DCU's first chapter. #superman #jamesgunn #moviereview #filmcritic #DCU