Beyond the infamous Salem trials lies a haunting landscape of forgotten witch stories spanning four centuries of Massachusetts history. In this captivating interview with historian and anthropologist Peter Muise on “Paranormal Yakker” we uncover the heartbreaking tales of ordinary people whose lives were destroyed by superstition, fear, and social conflict.
The Puritans who settled Massachusetts in the 1620s brought with them a deep-rooted fear of witchcraft, codified into law by 1641. What's particularly fascinating is how witch accusations followed consistent patterns—targeting those who didn't conform to social expectations or had contentious relationships with neighbors. When misfortune struck a community, these already-marginalized individuals became convenient supernatural scapegoats.
Peter shares the tragic story of Margaret Jones, Massachusetts' first executed witch in 1648, whose only "crime" was being an effective healer. Her simple remedies like "anise seeds steeped in red wine" aroused suspicion rather than appreciation. Even more surprising is the tale of Ann Hibbins, a wealthy merchant's wife, proving that social standing offered no protection against witchcraft accusations when one fell out of political favor.
We explore the evolution of witchcraft beliefs through the stories of Dogtown, a haven for outcasts where women made their living as "witches" selling remedies and fortune-telling services; Elizabeth Knapp, a servant girl who claimed the devil tempted her to murder; and the immortality-seeking alchemist Ephraim Gray whose corpse allegedly went missing. Perhaps most memorable is "Half-Hanged Mary" Webster, who survived a hanging attempt and later inspired her descendant Margaret Atwood's "The Handmaid's Tale."
These forgotten histories reveal how easily societies can turn against their most vulnerable members when fear overrides reason. What would you have done if your butter wouldn't churn or your bread wouldn't rise in 1690s Massachusetts? Who among your neighbors might you have condemned?
Witches and Warlocks of Massachusetts: Legends, Victims, and Sinister Spellcasters, Salem Witch Trials, Peter Muise, Puritans, Margaret Jones, Elizabeth Knapp, Ephraim Gray, Half-Hanged Mary Webster, The Handmaid’s Tale, Dogtown, immortality, elixir, bewitched, malevolent spirits, Paranormal, Paranormal Yakker, Stan Mallow
Send us a text