In the quiet coastal town of Jupiter, Florida, a brutal crime shattered the sense of safety in a close-knit community—and decades later, the truth still hasn’t been uncovered.

In this episode, we examine the mysterious and heartbreaking murder of Rachel Hurley, a 14-year-old whose life was taken. Rachel was found in a crowded park on St. Patrick's Day, with family and friends close by. Despite extensive investigations, multiple theories, and years of public speculation, no one has ever been charged.

We walk through the timeline of Rachel’s final hours, the evidence discovered at the scene, and the theories that have emerged over the years—from possible suspects to overlooked leads. We also explore how a crime like this could remain unsolved in a quiet town and what investigators believe might finally bring answers.

More than three decades later, Rachel Hurley’s case remains one of Florida’s most haunting unsolved murders.

If you have any information related to this case, please call crime stoppers at 1-800-458-8477.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

In May 2007, three-year-old Madeleine McCann vanished from her family’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, Portugal—triggering one of the most widely reported missing person cases in modern history. What began as a family vacation quickly became an international mystery filled with shifting theories, global media coverage, controversial investigations, and unanswered questions that still haunt investigators nearly two decades later.

In this episode, we trace the timeline from the night Madeleine disappeared to the massive search efforts that followed. We explore the early police response, the intense scrutiny placed on her parents, the emergence of suspects, and the role the media played in shaping public opinion. Along the way, we examine the evidence, the missteps, and the lingering theories that continue to fuel debate around the world.

Was Madeleine taken by a stranger? Could critical mistakes in the early investigation have changed the outcome? And why, after all these years, does this case remain unresolved?

Join us as we carefully unpack the facts, the speculation, and the enduring mystery behind the disappearance of Madeleine McCann—one of the most haunting true crime cases of our time.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

In May 2007, three-year-old Madeleine McCann vanished from her family’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, Portugal—triggering one of the most widely reported missing person cases in modern history. What began as a family vacation quickly became an international mystery filled with shifting theories, global media coverage, controversial investigations, and unanswered questions that still haunt investigators nearly two decades later.

In this episode, we trace the timeline from the night Madeleine disappeared to the massive search efforts that followed. We explore the early police response, the intense scrutiny placed on her parents, the emergence of suspects, and the role the media played in shaping public opinion. Along the way, we examine the evidence, the missteps, and the lingering theories that continue to fuel debate around the world.

Was Madeleine taken by a stranger? Could critical mistakes in the early investigation have changed the outcome? And why, after all these years, does this case remain unresolved?

Join us as we carefully unpack the facts, the speculation, and the enduring mystery behind the disappearance of Madeleine McCann—one of the most haunting true crime cases of our time.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

The community of Scottsdale, Arizona was awoken by a large explosion at the Fisher house. Inside, authorities located the bodies of Mary and her two kids, Brittney and Robert Jr. But dad and husband Robert Fisher was missing. It has now been almost 25 years since Robert went on the run and we still have no clue where he is or what happened to him.

If you have any information regarding the whereabouts of Robert Fisher please call the FBI Phoenix field office at 623-466-1999 or online at tips.fbi.gov.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

We sat down with Jeremy Hutchinson for a discussion on a wide range of topics. Jeremy grew up in Arkansas’ most recognizable political families, served as a state senator, representative, state prosecutor, and attorney. He also spent time in prison, before a pardon by President Trump.

His perspective and work in criminal justice reform is refreshing and definitely worth a listen.

Be sure to check out unifyus.us, for more information on what we can do to help fix our current criminal justice system.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

Jessica Easterly opened up to friends and family about being in an abusive relationship. But, just as she was trying to leave…Jessica went missing. The case into the death of Jessica Easterly has NOT been investigated.

Be sure to check out Justice4Jessica.org for more information and links to sign the necessary petitions.

You can also contact District Attorney Jason Williams at 504-822-2414 to demand an investigation or call in an anonymous tip to Crime Stoppers online or by calling 504-822-1111.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

On Mother’s Day in 2020, Suzanne Morphew went missing after what appeared to be a bicycle accident near her home in Colorado. The search for Suzanne was vast but eventually ended up back to the home - specifically her husband Barry. Holly goes through all of the details we have so far, so catch up in time for the trial that is set to begin later this year.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!

In 2018, the country was rocked by the story of a missing pregnant wife and her two young daughters. Immediately everyone thought the husband’s story wasn’t adding up. Kate gives a breakdown of the murders of Shanann, Bella, Celeste, and Nico.

For more information, check out overmydeadpod.com and @overmydeadpod on social media!