She started at the front desk of a small-town brokerage in 2005, took a pay cut to do it, and had no idea she'd still be there 20 years later — as co-broker owner.
Lindsay Hart is a licensed REALTOR and Co-Broker Owner at RE/MAX in Ithaca, New York, and the host of the podcast Under Contract Taking Backup. In this episode, Lindsay joins JMan and Jeffrey Scott Stanton on Outside the Corporate Box to talk about the slow, unsexy path from office admin to brokerage partner — and why that path built her in ways no shortcut ever could.
She breaks down what really made her leave a steady paycheck (it wasn't confidence, it was her husband and a savings account), how she built Hart & Homes from a solo act to a six-person team by accident, and the one philosophy that runs every decision she makes inside the brokerage.
She also gets honest about fake-extortion, bad reviews, confrontation, COVID killing her brokerage launch, and what she tells herself when business gets slow.
If you've ever wondered whether the slow path is the right one — this one's for you.
CHAPTERS:
00:00 – Cold Open
07:00 – Before Real Estate: Ithaca, Waitressing, and the Table That Changed Everything
13:00 – Learning the Hard Way: Subcontractors, Taxes, and Crying in Front of a CPA
17:00 – Sold on Real Estate: The Day a Broker Asked Her for a Job
24:00 – Starting From the Bottom Up: What the Front Desk Teaches You
31:00 – Why She Actually Left the Steady Paycheck
36:00 – Bad Reviews, Extortion, and the Art of Not Addressing Everything
43:00 – Building Hart & Homes: A Team That Found Her
47:00 – Relationships Before Business: The Philosophy That Runs Everything
52:00 – From Team Leader to Co-Broker Owner — and Then COVID
01:02:00 – What Centers Her When Things Get Slow
01:07:00 – The Last Question: What Would You Tell Yourself on Day One?
GUEST:
Lindsay Hart is a licensed REALTOR and Co-Broker Owner at RE/MAX in Ithaca, New York. She has spent two decades building her business from the ground up — starting as an office administrator in 2005, earning her license in 2007, launching her team Hart & Homes in 2017, and becoming co-broker owner alongside Melissa Miller in 2020. She is also the co-host of Under Contract Taking Backup, a podcast covering real estate, taxes, and life as a working agent.
Find Lindsay:
Website: LindsayHartRealtor.com
Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lindsayhart/
Radio Show: Knock Knock Property Talk — WHCU 607 News Talk Radio, Saturdays at 9:30 AM
SPONSORS
Wise Agent | wiseagent.com — The all-in-one CRM that helps real estate agents manage contacts, automate follow-up, and grow their business.
Subi | oksubi.com — Your AI transaction genie. From contract to close, your work is my command.
The CE Shop | theceshop.com — Online real estate education designed to fit your schedule and keep your career moving forward.
SUBSCRIBE to Outside the Corporate Box for new episodes every Monday.
Outside the Corporate Box is part of J Squared Podcast Productions — a premium media network built for professionals who want more than entertainment.