Leah describes a "holy silence" that followed the birth, a quietness so profound it felt as though the entire world was holding its breath. This peace is soon interrupted by a frantic pounding at the inn door. Five breathless shepherds arrive, trembling and wide-eyed, claiming they have been led to the cave by a celestial vision. Though Simon is initially skeptical, questioning if the men are simply drunk, they describe a terrifying and beautiful encounter in the hills where the sky burned with radiance and an angelic voice announced the birth of a Savior, providing the specific sign of a baby "wrapped in cloths and lying in a manger."

Moved by their earnestness, Leah overrules Simon’s hesitation and leads the dusty, lowly men into the cave just as the first light of dawn begins to break. As they enter, the shepherds are overcome by the humility of the scene, falling to their knees in reverence before the sleeping infant. Through their song, "We Saw the Sky Open," they recount how a "fire split the heavens" and transformed their fear into a desperate search for the Savior. Mary, weary but beaming, welcomes them with a gentle grace, observing that while the child looks ordinary, "most miracles do."

The episode concludes with the shepherds departing to spread the news throughout Bethlehem and beyond, their hearts full of the angelic message of peace and glory. Watching them leave, Simon is struck by the humbling realization that despite their lack of room, the King arrived anyway. Leah reflects on the night with a transformed perspective, realizing that Ruth’s prophecies had been fulfilled in her very midst. She understands at last that while they were nearly too exhausted to notice, God in His mercy opened their door to the eternal, signaling that the world has fundamentally changed.