In Episode 20 of Rebels by Design Wrestling, we dive headfirst into one of the hottest debates in pro wrestling: David Meltzer’s 5-star match ratings. Did they really not have a 5-star match? Or is wrestling greatness sometimes bigger than the stars it earns? If you’re a pro wrestling fan, podcast listener, or someone who lives for compelling ring psychology, explosive match moments, and passionate wrestling discussion, this episode swings for the fences.

We break down the history of the Meltzer rating system, explore legendary near-perfect bouts, compare eras from classic territory days to modern AEW, WWE, NJPW, and indie masterpieces, and challenge the myth that only a handful of matches truly deserve the top score. Expect thoughtful analysis, spirited debate, and the kind of wrestling conversation that feels like arguing with your friends after a pay-per-view at 1 a.m.

Whether you’re a wrestler chasing your own five-star story or a fan hunting for your next unforgettable match to binge, this video is built for you. Pro wrestling storytelling, match quality debates, top-tier wrestling analysis, and passionate fan perspective all collide right here.

Hit play, subscribe, and sound off in the comments with your five-star picks. Let’s talk wrestling the way it should be talked about: with conviction, curiosity, and a little chaos.