Send us Fan Mail

A preacher who has been married five times can preach the greatest sermon about the home you've ever heard. The exegesis flawless. The structure airtight. Every word of it true.

And it won't land.

Not because the message is wrong — but because in preaching, the messenger is never separate from the message.

Christian preachers have long tipped their clerical hats to Aristotle's three rhetorical categories: logos — the message, ethos — the speaker, and pathos — the audience. Secular rhetoricians like Quintilian and Cicero paid homage to them. Christians from Augustine forward have done the same. And what all of them have borne witness to across twenty centuries is this: more than the words count.

In this episode, Jonathan McClintock works through what happens when those three categories don't line up — when a preacher's ethos undermines his logos, or when a dry, monotone delivery lets pathos overwhelm a message that was entirely true.

What this episode covers:

Why your integrity carries content — and why the congregation hears your words through what they know about your life.

Why a sermon can be doctrinally sound and still fail to land, and what that means for how you think about delivery.

The quiet trap some preachers fall into — diminishing their own role in the preaching event out of a desire to give God the glory, until they almost fear preaching with passion. As the episode puts it: it's as though they feel they aren't actually preaching unless they give the Holy Spirit an obstacle to overcome.

Solomon Stoddard's challenge — the grandfather and greatest influence of Jonathan Edwards, who argued that sermons read are not delivered with authority, that they savor the sermons of the scribes, and that the liveliness of the preacher is a means God uses to stir the affections of the hearer.

And the sentence that holds it all together: God uses the passion of the messenger to stir the passions of the listener, and to confront his mind with the urgency of a decision to accept or reject the message.

Your passion is not a distraction from the Spirit's work. It is one of the instruments the Spirit uses. Your delivery is not the packaging around the truth — it is part of how the truth arrives.