I'll be honest with you. The first time I really sat with this passage, the question Jesus asks made me a little uncomfortable. Not because it seemed cruel — but because I recognized myself in the man's answer.

Jesus walks up to someone who has been ill for thirty-eight years and asks, "Do you want to be made well?"

Which sounds almost absurd. Of course he does. What kind of question is that?

But notice what the man says. He doesn't say yes. He explains why healing hasn't happened yet. He's got the whole system figured out — the pool, the stirring of the water, the people who get there ahead of him. Thirty-eight years of the same obstacle, recited like a script he's memorized so well he's stopped hearing it.

Jesus asked if he wanted to be healed. The man answered with his limitations.

I don't say that to be hard on him. Thirty-eight years is a long time. Long enough for a situation to stop feeling like a situation and start feeling like an identity. Long enough for the waiting to become its own kind of life.

And if I'm being honest, I've done the same thing. Maybe not with physical illness, but with other things I've carried a long time. Old wounds I've tended so carefully started to feel like they belonged to me. Patterns I've complained about for years without ever quite deciding to change. Grudges that have become such familiar furniture that I've stopped noticing them.

Jesus's question has a way of cutting through all of that. Do you want to be made well?

Not "can you be made well." Not "here's how the healing works." Just — do you want it? Because wanting it, really wanting it, means being willing to let go of the story you've been telling about why it hasn't happened yet.

The man at the pool didn't get a chance to answer. Jesus didn't wait. He just said: Stand up. Take your mat. Walk.

Which is its own kind of grace. Sometimes Jesus acts before we've fully sorted out whether we're ready.

But the question still hangs in the air for the rest of us. Do you want to be made well from whatever you've been lying beside for longer than you'd like to admit?

It's worth sitting with. Really sitting with. Because the answer might be more complicated than we expect.

Lord Jesus, you see us where we are, and you know how long we've been there. Give us the courage to want healing more than we want our explanations. And when we're not sure we're ready, come to us anyway. Amen.

This devotional was written and read by Cliff McCartney

Grace for All is a daily devotional podcast produced by the members of the congregation of First United Methodist Church in Maryville, Tennessee. With these devotionals, we want to remind listeners on a daily basis of the love and grace that God extends to all human beings, no matter their location, status, or condition in life.

If you would like to respond to these devotionals in any way, we would enjoy hearing from you. Our email address is: podcasts@1stchurch.org.

First United Methodist Church is a lively, spirit-filled congregation whose goal is to spread the message of love and grace into our community and throughout the world. We are located on the web at https://1stchurch.org/.