In 1993, Amarillo lawyer David Glenn Lewis vanished, leaving behind a home that suggested he planned to return. His watch and wedding ring were on the counter, sandwiches were in the fridge, and the VCR kept recording the Super Bowl after he was gone. Then, less than two days later, an unidentified man was killed on a highway near Moxee, Washington. It would take eleven years to learn they were the same person. In this episode, we trace the strange timeline, the missing hours, and the unanswered question at the center of the case: how did David Glenn Lewis end up 1,600 miles from home?

In November 1980, Granger Taylor, a 32-year-old mechanic from Duncan, British Columbia, disappeared after leaving behind one of the strangest notes ever found in a missing person case, telling his parents he was leaving on a 42-month journey through space aboard an alien ship. Taylor was well known in his community for restoring old machines, including a steam locomotive and a World War II Kittyhawk aircraft, and for his deep interest in UFOs and outer space. Years later, investigators found truck wreckage, small human remains, and clothing believed to be connected to him on Mount Prevost, and authorities treated the discovery as the answer to the case. But because the remains were never confirmed through modern DNA testing, the disappearance of Granger Taylor still stands as one of Canada’s strangest and most debated mysteries.

From 1982 to 1985, Belgium was terrorized by a violent group known as the Brabant Killers, also called the Nivelles Gang, who carried out a string of brutal robberies and mass shootings that left 28 people dead, including children. What made the case especially disturbing was that the violence often seemed wildly disproportionate to the small amounts of money stolen, leading many to believe the killers may have had motives beyond ordinary robbery.

In 1984, the kidnapping of Glico president Katsuhisa Ezaki exploded into one of Japan’s most infamous unsolved criminal cases. What began as a ransom plot soon turned into a nationwide campaign of extortion, poisoned candy threats, taunting letters to police and the press, and the hunt for a mysterious suspect known as the “Fox-Eyed Man.” In this episode, we break down the clues, the fear, and the mistakes that allowed the Monster with 21 Faces to vanish without ever being identified.

In 1948, 21-year-old Mary Virginia “Jimmie” Carpenter arrived in Denton, Texas, to attend summer classes at Texas State College for Women — but after stepping out of a cab near Brackenridge Hall, she vanished without a trace. In this episode, we examine her final known movements, the mysterious clues left behind, and the theories that still surround her disappearance.

When West Point cadet Richard Colvin Cox walked out to meet a mysterious man on a cold January night in 1950, no one realized it would be the last time he’d ever be seen. In this episode, we examine the baffling disappearance of the young cadet, the strange leads that followed, and the questions that still remain unanswered decades later.

Listener discretion

This episode discusses a real-life disappearance and themes involving missing persons and investigative uncertainty.