Should women be criminally punished for abortion?

Dear Jane is back for 2026, and Part 2 of this two-part conversation goes straight into one of the most uncomfortable debates inside the pro-life movement. Hosts Scott and Marcie sit down with Clark Forsythe of Americans United for Life to unpack why holding women legally responsible isn’t as simple—or as effective—as some think.

They talk honestly about what’s changed in a post–abortion pill world, why self-managed abortions complicate everything, and which laws actually reduce abortion versus the ones that sound strong but miss the mark. This isn’t theory. It’s history, law, and real-world consequences—all on the table.

If you’ve ever wondered where accountability should land, how women are truly impacted, or where the movement goes from here… this episode is for you.

Guest: Clark Forsythe, Senior Counsel, Americans United for Life

🔗 aul.org

Facebook: Americans United for Life

X: @aul

Dear Jane is back for 2026, and hosts Scott and Marcie are diving straight into one of the most controversial debates in the pro-life movement. In Part 1 of a two-part series, they sit down with constitutional attorney Bradley Pierce, President of the Foundation to Abolish Abortion, who argues that our laws should hold women criminally responsible for abortion.

This episode tackles hard questions about justice, deterrence, and whether current laws are actually ending abortion. Next week, Scott and Marcie return with Clark Forsythe of Americans United for Life to make the case against criminalization in Part 2.

Guest: Bradley Pierce – President, Foundation to Abolish Abortion

Guest Socials:

Website: https://faa.life/

Facebook: / abolitionistfaa

Instagram: / abolitionistfaa

X: https://x.com/AbolitionistFAA

YouTube: / @abolitionistfaa

Some states are stepping up to protect life. Others are trying to silence it. Across the country, pregnancy centers and pro-life organizations are being hit with unconstitutional laws designed to shut them down.

In this episode, Peter Breen from the Thomas More Society breaks down the legal threats facing pro-life efforts and how they're fighting back. It's a clear look at the battle ahead and how the movement plans to win.

To support the vital work of the Thomas More Society, please visit: https://www.thomasmoresociety.org/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thomasmoresoc/

X: https://x.com/ThomasMoreSoc

Abortion isn’t just a political debate—it’s a biblical mandate for the Church to address. Pastor Eric Jones, founder of Pro-Life Pastors, joins us to share why defending life is a Gospel issue. From the pulpit to the public square, we discuss why pastors must speak boldly on abortion and equip their congregations to stand for life with truth and compassion.

YouTube: https://www.prolifepastors.org/

What happens when a state removes every restriction on abortion — and bans life-saving alternatives? Welcome to Colorado, where abortion is virtually unregulated and Abortion Pill Reversal is now illegal. In this episode, we go deep inside one of America’s most extreme abortion battlegrounds.

Rich Bennett, President and CEO of Life Network in Colorado Springs, joins us to reveal what it’s like to run a pro-life pregnancy center in a state that’s become a magnet for out-of-state abortions. As abortion pills flood Colorado, Rich shares how his team is holding the line — adapting, innovating, and offering hope where it’s needed most. This is the frontlines of the life movement. Don’t miss this raw and powerful conversation from ground zero in the abortion debate.

What is it about Louisiana that has empowered so many Black pro-life advocates to step forward? Our guests today are Tara and Mike Wicker from Louisiana Black Advocates for Life. They share how Louisiana’s cultural landscape has shaped it into a pro-life state, and the challenges they continue to face within the Black community and local churches. This episode of Dear Jane takes a closer look at how culture shapes the conversation around life and advocacy.

Website: www.lablackadvocates.com

Instagram: www.instagram.com/lablackadvocates

Facebook: www.facebook.com/lablackadvocates#prolifenews

What if one conversation could change everything? What Changes Minds About Abortion? This week on Dear Jane, Emily Geiger from Equal Rights Institute joins us to unpack the art and strategy of pro-life dialogue.

In a culture saturated with soundbites and polarization, Emily offers a thoughtful, truth-driven approach to navigating even the toughest pro-choice arguments — without compromising clarity or compassion. If you’ve ever hesitated to speak up, felt unsure what to say, or feared doing more harm than good, this episode will give you the confidence and tools to engage with conviction.

Website: https://equalrightsinstitute.com/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/equal_rights_institute/

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@EqualRightsInstitute/shorts

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/EqualRightsInstitute X: https://x.com/GeigerEmilyA

For 16 years, Mayra Rodriguez ran a Planned Parenthood clinic—until she saw the truth. Botched abortions. Covered-up injuries. No accountability. When she spoke out, they tried to silence her. Now she’s exposing the abortion industry from the inside.

Learn More

Website: https://mayrarodriguez.org/en_us/

Linkt.ree: https://linktr.ee/RMayra

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheRealMayraRodriguez/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/therealmayra.rodriguez/

X: https://x.com/TheRealMayraRdz

YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/@mayrarodriguezpslam18