Every ghost story deserves a good cup of coffee. ☕️ Tonight we dive into the chilling case of Herbert Mullin, the self-styled “prophet” who believed human sacrifice could stop California earthquakes. This is Santa Cruz at its most haunted—where psychosis, fear, and failure of systems collided.

What’s inside: • Early years, grief, and the first cracks in reality • The “divine mission” and voices that demanded blood • A four-month killing spree across Santa Cruz County • Arrest, trial, and the question: evil or untreated illness? • Legacy, lessons, and how communities heal

Sponsors & Shout-outs: Huge thanks to our sponsors for keeping the mugs full and the mics hot. Special shout-out to Care and the crew at Dutch Bros in Flagstaff, AZ—thanks for always being happy to see us and fueling our late-night edits!

Mental Health Resources: If you or someone you know is struggling with mental illness, please reach out. In the U.S., call or text 988 for the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. You’re not alone.

Connect & Support: • Subscribe for more creepy, caffeinated stories • Rate & review—it helps others find the show • Merch & show notes: CreepyCoffees.com • Email: Contact@CreepyCoffees.com

In this chilling episode of Creepy Coffees, Eddie Ravenscar takes you inside the brand-new studio build—where something isn’t quite right. What should have been a fresh start quickly turns unsettling when a single box fan begins to move on its own, the dividing rods spell out an eerie “YES,” and the EMF meter refuses to stay silent.

Is the studio simply settling in, or is something else moving in with it? Grab your favorite roast, dim the lights, and join Eddie as he dives into the strange happenings of the haunted workspace, exploring whether this is coincidence, energy, or a full-on presence making itself known.

☕👻 Pour a cup and settle in—it’s time to find out what’s really hiding in the shadows of the studio.

What does it mean when our demons don’t just haunt our minds… but follow us into the dark corners of our lives? In this chilling episode of Creepy Coffees, Eddie Ravenscar confronts the idea of “Demons Dancing”—the struggles that trail behind us like shadows we can’t shake.

From the very real battles with personal demons—grief, addiction, and fear—to eerie tales where people swore they felt something far more sinister on their heels, this episode dances on the thin line between psychological torment and supernatural possession.

☕ Along the way, we’ll uncover historical accounts, chilling case studies, and modern-day stories where the “dance” becomes all too real. And yes—we’ll take our Coffee Break to sip something dark and bold enough to keep the night at bay.

Are your demons real… or are they dancing just out of sight?

The Door with No Number: Secrets of the Monte Vista

Downtown Flagstaff’s historic Monte Vista Hotel has a long list of ghost stories — but one stands out from the rest. Tucked away in its halls is a mysterious guest room with no plaque, no number… and no welcome mat.

Once open to travelers, this room became the source of terrifying reports: whispers from an empty closet, phantom footsteps pacing in the dark, the smell of pipe smoke, and ghostly figures who appear at the foot of the bed. Then came the incident that changed everything — a staff member locked inside, from the outside, with no one in the hall.

In this episode, we search for the infamous door, share chilling firsthand accounts, and explore the theories behind one of Arizona’s most haunted hotel mysteries.

Will you walk past it… or will you knock?

Tom: Don’t Say His Name

A shadow from childhood. A name that shouldn’t be spoken. In this episode, Eddie Ravenscar unpacks a personal haunting that may have followed him across states—and possibly into someone else’s home. Is Tom just a figment of imagination, or something much more real?

Hidden deep in Amherst, Ohio, stands the Nabakowski Mansion—once the pride of three wealthy physician brothers, now a decaying shell of grief, betrayal, and death.

In this episode, Eddie and Dawn brew up a chilling tale of love turned lethal, where jealousy ran deeper than blood… and murder wasn’t the end. A maid, pregnant and silenced. Brothers torn apart by violence. And a self termination in the barn that still casts a swinging shadow under moonlight.

Some say the third floor still holds the maid’s sorrow. Others swear they’ve seen a figure swaying in the rafters when the moon is right.

Come for the story. Stay for the spirits.

Because in this house… nothing stays buried.

Ep 19

“Blood in the Bakery: The Unsolved Dolly Madison Murders”

On a quiet evening in Great Bend, Kansas, two lives were brutally taken inside the Dolly Madison Bakery Outlet.

Mandi Alexander, a 24-year-old employee just four days into her new job…

Mary Drake, a 79-year-old grandmother stopping in for a loaf of bread.

Both murdered. No arrests. No motive. No peace.

Over two decades later, the case remains unsolved—but a shocking DNA breakthrough and a community-driven documentary have breathed new life into the investigation.

In this chilling episode of Creepy Coffees, Eddie and Dawn Ravenscar unravel the haunting details behind the 2002 double homicide, explore theories, retrace the investigation, and ask the questions that still demand answers.

Could you be the missing piece?

☕ Grab a cup. Lock your doors.

This one stays with you.

Clock out, pour a fresh cup, and get ready to dive into one of the most baffling unsolved crimes in American history. In this episode, Eddie and Dawn Ravenscar investigate The Burger Chef Murders—a chilling 1978 case where four young employees vanished from a fast food restaurant in Speedway, Indiana… only to be found brutally murdered days later.

We break down the eerie timeline, the strange crime scene, the botched investigation, and the countless theories that still haunt this case nearly 50 years later. Was it a robbery gone wrong? A targeted hit? Or something even darker?

Plus: our weekly coffee review, a few ghostly coincidences tied to the case, and that one piece of evidence we still can’t stop talking about.

☕ Featuring:

Peet’s Big Bang Medium Roast Coffee (K-Cup Review)

• Full case timeline & breakdown
• Theories, suspects, and paranormal parallels
• A haunting closing you won’t forget

🎧 Stream now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube & everywhere else you get your creepy fix.

#CreepyCoffees #BurgerChefMurders #TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #FastFoodHorror #IndianaCrime #ColdCaseFiles #ParanormalPodcast #HorrorPodcast #GhostHunters #CreepyCoffeeBreak #CoffeeAndCrime #RavenscarInvestigations #SpookySeason