In this explosive episode of No Contest, hosts Claudia King, Josh Kolsrud, and Holland Reid break down the shocking OnlyFans model Courtney Clenney (aka Courtney Tailor) murder case. Charged with second-degree murder in the April, 2022, stabbing death of her boyfriend, Christian Obumseli, Clenney claims self-defense, but her story raises major red flags.

How did a thrown knife allegedly plunge 3 inches deep into Obumseli’s chest from across the room? We dissect her bizarre account, the forensic evidence that challenges it, and the toxic relationship dynamics at play. Was this a clear case of domestic violence with one abuser and one victim, or were both Courtney Clenney and Christian Obumseli caught in a mutually abusive cycle? We also tackle the racial undertones of the case, with Clenney being white and Obumseli black, and whether the defense will steer clear of this dynamic or try to use it in their case.

Plus, we explore the darker side of true crime fandom: Why are so many people drawn to writing letters to killers behind bars? And in the age of social media, do we ever really know anyone? With curated highlight reels showing only the best versions of ourselves, how often are people living completely different realities offline?

From Miami luxury apartment to courtroom delays (with the trial now pushed to August, 2026), this high-profile case is full of twists, contradictions, and uncomfortable questions about love, violence, and authenticity.

If you love deep dives into controversial true crime cases, domestic violence debates, and the psychology of crime and attraction, this is one you don’t want to miss.

Tune in to No Contest with Claudia King, Josh Kolsrud, and Holland Reid. Self-defense or something more sinister? Who do you think was the real abuser?

Subscribe for more unfiltered true crime discussions, hit the notification bell, and leave a review on your favorite podcast app!

Josh, Claudia, and Holland can be seen regularly on Court TV, Nancy Grace, and local News programs. No Contest features the true crime cases they covered on the past Friday's show or other cases currently in the public spotlight. No Contest provides legal and social commentary. All opinions are those of the hosts.

Your No Contest Hosts:

Claudia King, Domestic Violence and Trauma Recovery Specialist @realclaudiaking youarestrongenough.com

Joshua Kolsrud, Criminal Defense and Personal Injury Attorney @joshua_kolsrud kolsrudlawoffices.com 480.428.1865

Holland Reid, Pop Culture and Social Media Expert, Photographer, Actress @official_holland_reid

Follow No Contest on Instagram @thenocontestpodcast