Capture This! is a podcast series that shines a light on failing councils, collapsing cities and the communities at the helm of the resistance.

This second episode, draws on a recently published report by researcher Jonathan van der Walt (https://beyondstatecapture.org.za/reports/) which deals with municipal mismanagement in South Africa.

Hosted by filmmaker, Tsogo Kupa we explore the causes and various aspects of municipal mismanagement as well as the story of Makhanda: a story of how anyone can make a change in their town or city. Featuring insights from researcher Jonathan Van Der Walt and Legal Resources Centre lawyer, Cecile Van Schalwyk, as well as perspectives from the Makhanda Citizen’s Front, we aim to present a clear picture of municipal mismanagement and how only getting organised at community level can stop the rot.

In the podcast

• The vision of what municipalities should’ve looked like in democratic South Africa and what went wrong.
• An overview of Municipal Mismanagement Report:

Cadre deployment, people placed in roles they aren’t qualified for, poor planning and corruption within public procurement.

• Litigation against Makhanda’s Municipality.
• What happened in Makhanda and how an organization of ordinary people made a difference.
• What’s currently happening in Makhanda.
• How individuals can make a change within their municipalities.

Key Takeaways:

Topic 1: [00:02:08:09 - 00:10:27:22] Municipal Mismanagement research report outlined by Jonathan van der Walt and Tsogo Kupa.

Topic 2: [00:10:57:14 - 00:11:46:04] Overview of how an organization of ordinary people in Makhanda made a difference in the Makhana Municipality.

Topic 3: [00:11:49:13 - 00:13:53:13] Cecile Van Schalwyk on litigation against Makhanda’s Municipality.

Topic 4: [00:14:03:15 - 00:16:22:10] Residents of Makhanda share how they contested the local elections.

Topic 5: [00:16:23:06 - 00:17:41:10] What’s currently happening in Makhanda.

Topic 6: [00:17:50:09 - 00:20:48:12] How individuals can make a change within their municipalities.

Links to Sources:

Municipal Mismanagement Report Link: https://beyondstatecapture.org.za/reports/

• Subscribe to our newsletter! zc.vg/0wqgs
• “Follow us on Social media” here:

Facebook:

www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61559659002294

X:

https://x.com/capture_beyond

YouTube:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4izraQCTPruutz1AGIB9NA

Instagram:

https://www.instagram.com/beyondstatecapture/

TikTok:

https://www.tiktok.com/@statecaptureandbeyond?_t=ZS-8zPsXLZXR3a&_r=1

Threads:

Capture This! is a podcast series that shines a light on failing councils, collapsing cities and the communities at the helm of the resistance.

This first episode, draws on a recently published report by researcher Jonathan van der Walt beyondstatecapture.org.za/water-report/ which deals with the spectacular failure to provide the essential life force we all need to survive – water. Hosted by filmmaker, Tsogo Kupa and human rights advocate, Eldonna Muhwava, we explore the causes of the water crisis, the legal context, and the reasons behind the government's inability to address the issue effectively. Featuring insights from water justice advocates and perspectives from communities directly affected, we aim to present a clear picture of the crisis and its impact on people's lives.

In the podcast

• An overview of recently released research report ‘Shallow Justice’
• Contributions from experts, activists, and individuals affected by the ongoing water crisis.
• A discussion on systemic obstacles to achieving substantive justice.
• Considerations about the future: possibilities for achieving genuine justice and moving beyond state capture.

Key Takeaways:

Topic 1: [00;02;45;18 - 00;03;47;14] Shallow Justice research report outlined by Jonathan van der Walt and Eldonna Muhwava.

Topic 2: [00;04;00;23 - 00;05;27;09] Michael Makhwara, principal of a Soweto high school on the impacts of no water in his school.

Topic 3: [00;05;59;16 - 00;08;27;25] Siphesihle Masondo and Nqobile Ndima, on impacts of anti-poor water policy on informal settlement residents in Phumla Mqashi.

Topic 4: [00;09;43;28 - 00;11;51;22] Water Justice activist, Koni Benson, on the deeper political context.

Topic 5: [00;15;01;19 - 00;21;14;02 ] Trevor Ngwane and Dale McKinley talk about the fight against privatisation and how privatisation has caused the crisis.

Topic 6: [00;26;37;00 - 00;29;08;06] Ingrid Bester from the Johannesburg Water Crisis Committee on why she was motivated into activism.

Links to Sources:

Shallow Justice Report: beyondstatecapture.org.za/water-report/

Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS) "Blue Drop: Watch Report 2023" (2023) available at ws.dws.gov.za/IRIS/latestresults.aspx

Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS) “Green Drop: Progress Assessment Report 2023” (2023) available at ws.dws.gov.za/iris/releases/GDWR.pdf

Tracy Ledger ‘Empty Promises: The struggle for equitable access to water in South Africa’ (2024) Public Affairs Research Institute (PARI) available at pari.org.za/report-empty-promises-the- struggle-for-equitable-access-to-water-in-south-africa

• Subscribe to our newsletter! zc.vg/0wqgs
• “Follow us on Social media” here
• www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61559659002294
• https://x.com/capture_beyond
• https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC4izraQCTPruutz1AGIB9NA