Frozen Pizza Taste Test Under $5 | Stay Outta My Fridge

Frozen Pizza Taste Test Under $5 is finally here, and Beard Laws, Avery and Isla are raiding the freezer to find out which budget frozen pizza deserves a spot in your kitchen. We bought six frozen pizzas from Aldi, Dollar General, Family Dollar and Save A Lot, kept every pizza under $5, and put them through a blind family taste test to crown the ultimate budget pizza champion.

Can a cheap frozen pizza actually beat the competition? That's exactly what we're finding out. From crispy thin crust pizzas to fluffy cheese pizzas and classic pepperoni, nobody knew which pizza came from which store until the final reveal. There were surprise winners, disappointing slices, plenty of laughs, and even a few cardboard-related cooking lessons along the way.

What's In The Fridge This Week

• Blind frozen pizza taste test under $5
• Aldi vs Dollar General vs Family Dollar vs Save A Lot
• Family food challenge with Beard Laws, Avery and Isla
• Budget grocery food review and taste test 2026
• The search for the best cheap frozen pizza

Stay Outta My Fridge is the show where the kids take over the kitchen. Join Beard Laws, Avery and Isla for the most chaotic food reviews on the internet as they test popular foods, compare grocery store favorites, discover hidden gems, and prove that great family memories don't have to cost a fortune.

Which frozen pizza would YOU choose? Did your favorite make the top of our rankings, or did one of these budget pizzas completely surprise you? Let us know your favorite frozen pizza brand in the comments and tell us what food challenge we should tackle next!

TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Cold Open

00:30 The Challenge Begins

01:29 - Initial impressions of the pizzas

02:17 - Challenges of finding affordable pizzas

02:44 - First pizza review: flat pepperoni

03:24 - Rating criteria and scoring scale

04:12 - Second pizza: another flat slice from Family Dollar

05:16 - Adding ranch for flavor testing

06:38 - Third pizza: thin crust pepperoni from Dollar General

08:23 - A thicker crust option from Aldi

09:32 - Testing a highly-spiced sauce pizza

11:06 - Cheese-only versions and weird flavor comments

12:11 - The D pizza: a fluffy thick crust option

13:32 - Ratings and feedback on each pizza

14:31 - Comparing the scores and narrowing the finalists

15:57 - Final analyses of the top contenders

17:53 - Ending thoughts on crust preferences and value

19:34 - Kitchen tips and safety advice for cooking frozen pizza

21:40 - Humorous reflections on budget pizza quality

23:23 - Final scores and determining the ultimate winner

25:23 - Discarding the lowest-ranked options

28:19 - Declaring the best value frozen pizza under five dollars

31:07 - Wrap-up, learnings, and parting comments

A proud production of the Beard Laws Network.

Subscribe for new Stay Outta My Fridge episodes every Thursday and join the family!

#StayOuttaMyFridge #BeardLawsNetwork #FrozenPizza #FoodReview #FamilyChallenge

If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe and leave a 5-star review on your favorite podcast app! It's the best way to help our family show reach more people.

This has been The Stay Outta My Fridge Podcast, your source for family comedy, snack reviews, and '90s nostalgia.

Find us on social media

The Stay Outta My Fridge Podcast is a part of the Bleav Network.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.