Pete Sellwood and Jackson Poppert join Vince for a preview of the biggest Brewer game of their lives. The trio analyzes what pitchers are available, offers some lineup suggestions and grapples with the consequences attached to a game filled with cinematic destiny. Also, Vince and Nathan Jahn unveil a few strategies for handling the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat when watching sports as fans.

Vince gets nostalgic for the old Wisconsin football, and Luke calls for drastic action to fix the Eagles' offense. Later, Vince gets some senior advice on how to strategically mention that it is his birthday, and a debate over what birthday presents the sports powers can provide.

Pete Sellwood joins Vince to recap a marvelous season of Brewers baseball. Pete pokes holes in Vince's "top 10 most important Brewers" ranking before the two hand out some unserious awards. Finally, some playoff predictions and what a Brewer fan's expectations should be going into postseason play.

Luke unveils which surprise NFC team has reached contender status and guest host Mekhi Ackerman argues that the Brewers' toughest playoff test is coming sooner than expected. Later, Vince and Luke make their MLB playoff predictions and compete to see who can find the funniest quotes in sports history.

Luke airs grievances after a disastrous Badgers performance while Vince scolds the fans who chanted "Fire Fickell." Browns fan Johnny Raider also swings by to make fun of the Packers. Finally, the best of NFL week three and an update on a baseball bet six months in the making.

Luke's brother Linus calls into the show to launch the Micah Parsons MVP campaign while Vince and Luke break down the best of NFL week two with a pair of top 5 lists. Also, Luke defends his Eagles from Vince's Packers propaganda.

(1:37) Rate my Take
(22:04) Laundry List/L of the Week
(30:33) Top 5 happiest people & top 5 "maybe"s of week 2
(43:15) Packers vs Eagles "best team in the NFC" debate

Vince celebrates the "Maddenification" of the NFL while Luke talks about the best and worst performances in NFL week 1. The two then discuss what hypothetical NFL scenarios would create the most hilarity and agony.

Luke, Evan, Vince and long-time host Alex Schuster dig into the vault and rerate some old takes from previous shows. The crew also debate how young LeBron would have to be before they could beat him in basketball and look back on the show's best moments.