Every PM is scrambling to learn AI tools - but is that a trap?

In this episode of Arguing Agile, hosts Brian Orlando and Om Patel summarize Shreyas Doshi's provocative article "Why Product Sense Is the Only Product Skill That Will Matter in the AI Age." Using the article as background for our discussion, we explore whether AI tools like Claude, Cursor, and NotebookLM are genuine superpowers for product managers or just the new baseline that everyone will have access to.

https://shreyasdoshi.substack.com/p/why-product-sense-is-the-only-product

We've structured this episode around several key debates, including:

🔹 AI Tool Usage: Are AI tools a temporary competitive advantage or just commoditized table stakes? When everyone has a bulldozer, the winner is the one who knows where to dig.

🔹 Strategy vs. Prompting: If you and your competitors use the same LLMs to write product strategy, how long until you're all building the exact same app? The hosts argue for using AI as a red teamer rather than an original thinker.

🔹 Speed of Conviction vs. Quality: Business leaders love saying "a fast B+ decision beats a slow A+ decision." But Brian and Om challenge this with Bezos' two-way door framework and evidence that AI-assisted workflows create 37% more rework.

🔹 Product Taste & Judgment: The hosts wrestle with Shreyas' concept of "product taste"—the ability to pick the optimal recommendation from a set of excellent AI-generated options and explain your reasoning.

🔹 The Zero-Cost Software Future: What happens when the cost of building software drops to zero? Will we end up at software bazaars with 30 identical prototypes? The hosts paint a vivid (and slightly terrifying) picture of commoditized software development.

#ProductManagement #AIProductManager #ProductSense

"Why Product Sense Is the Only Product Skill That Will Matter in the AI Age" by Shreyas Doshi (Substack article March 2026), Jeff Bezos' Disagree and Commit framework, Jeff Bezos' One-Way Door vs Two-Way Door decision framework, Claude by Anthropic, Claude Code, Cursor, NotebookLM, HubSpot, Jira, Figma, Google Docs, DataDog, MoSCoW Prioritization Framework, Stanford Cooper Bench Experiment (referenced from Arguing Agile Episode 247), Arguing Agile Episode 254 "QA: Why a Massive QA Boom Is Coming", Arguing Agile Episode 247 "A Poor Team Player - Stanford's Cooper Bench Experiment"

LINKS
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@arguingagile
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/362QvYORmtZRKAeTAE57v3
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/agile-podcast/id1568557596

INTRO MUSIC
Toronto Is My Beat
By Whitewolf (Source: https://ccmixter.org/files/whitewolf225/60181)
CC BY 4.0 DEED (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.en)