13 Deep Dive Gorgias the Nihilist

Gorgias of Leontini is a figure entrenched in the history of Western philosophical thought, particularly known for his early exploration of nihilism and skepticism during the 5th century BCE. As a sophist and rhetorician, Gorgias's ideas challenged the very nature of reality, knowledge, and truth. In this deep dive, we'll explore the nuances of his philosophical contributions, particularly in moral philosophy, dissecting not only his most famous arguments but also their enduring relevance in contemporary discourse.

Gorgias is particularly known for his work "On Non-Existence," or "On Nature," where he famously posits that nothing exists, and if something does exist, we cannot know it. This radical stance laid the groundwork for a type of skepticism that would echo through centuries. In fact, Gorgias’s assertion that perception and language shape our understanding of reality means that truth might be as elusive as a shadow. His approach can be traced as an early articulation of a defining problem in ethics and moral philosophy: the struggle to discern an objective moral truth in a world perceived very differently by each individual.

One of the central pieces of Gorgias’s argument is encapsulated succinctly in his refutation of existence. Gorgias entertains three main propositions: first, that nothing exists; second, if anything existed, we could not know it; and third, even if we could know it, we couldn’t communicate that knowledge to others. Let’s break these down in a way that illuminates their implications for morality.

Selenius Media