Send us Fan Mail

What does it actually take to build an insurance business from $0 to more than $2 million in premium in just four years?

For Stacie Warner, it wasn't buying leads.

It wasn't spending hours every day cold calling.

And it definitely wasn't constantly pitching insurance on social media.

In this episode of The Modern Insurance Agent Podcast, David Denning sits down with Stacie Warner, owner of Warner Twins Insurance Services, to break down how she built a thriving commercial insurance business by choosing a niche, building genuine relationships, using social media consistently, and turning happy clients into a powerful source of referrals.

Stacie specializes in helping contractors with their commercial insurance needs and she built her practice almost entirely through relationships, referrals, and social media.

You'll discover:

• How Stacie went from the restaurant industry to owning an insurance business
• Why she chose contractors as her insurance niche
• The two major insurance problems she sees contractors struggle with
• How she grew from $0 to $2M+ in premium in four years
• Why buying leads never felt right for the way she wanted to build her business
• What changed when she started intentionally using social media
• How she went from HATING being on camera to consistently showing up online
• Why she focuses on relationships instead of pitching people in the DMs
• How contractors started finding her through Facebook
• Why roughly 50% of her book of business now comes from referrals
• How Centers of Influence and strategic referral partners accelerated her growth
• Why Facebook groups became one of her biggest opportunities
• How she manages her social media in roughly 25 minutes a day
• Why personal content is an important part of her insurance marketing strategy
• How clients started tagging and recommending her even when she wasn't actively marketing
• Why AI won't eliminate the need for a knowledgeable insurance agent
• How Stacie balances building a growing agency while raising twin boys
• Her vision for eventually building a $1 million revenue insurance agency

One of the biggest turning points came when Stacie stopped wondering where her next lead would come from and started building a system around relationships and visibility.

After implementing the strategy, contractors began reaching out to her on Facebook. Then those contractors referred other contractors. Eventually, clients started tagging her whenever someone in their communities asked for commercial insurance recommendations.

Today, Stacie estimates approximately 50% of her book comes from referrals including referrals that originated from relationships she initially built through social media.

And here's what makes her social strategy especially interesting:

She's not spending all day creating content.

Stacie says she spends about 25 minutes at most on Facebook, sharing a mix of her personal life, helpful content, and occasional educational business posts. Instead of constantly saying, "Buy insurance from me," she lets people get to know her and understand what she does over time.

That consistency has created something even more valuable than another lead source:

A community of people willing to advocate for her.

Her clients and sometimes people who haven't even worked with her yet tag Stacie when contractors ask for insurance recommendations inside Facebook groups.

If you're an insurance agent who's tired of transactional lead generation and wants to build a business around relationships, referrals, social media, and becoming the go-to agent in your niche, this is an episode you don't want to miss.

Connect with Us:

🔗Download the resources & access the full podcast library – jumpstartgonow.com/podcast

Join the Movement of Modern Insurance Agents!

Ready to become the agent clients trust and refer to their friends? Start by building your personal brand, using social media effectively, and prioritizing relationships over transactions. Let’s change the way people see insurance one client at a time! 🚀

📢 Join the discussion! Connect with like-minded agents and get exclusive marketing tips in the Marketing for Insurance Agents Facebook Group. jumpstartgonow.com/join-group