The Kimes family’s story twists ever tighter.

Even with George and Matthew Kimes locked behind McAlester’s walls, their name still carried the echo of gunfire and scandal.

Episode 6 follows the aftermath of the Beggs murders and Matt’s death sentence, the brothers’ long years under a new warden’s reforms, and the chaos that continued to orbit their sister Nellie—whose every attempt at a normal life seemed doomed by the weight of her family’s infamy.

From courtroom reversals and prison “watermelon feasts” to a mysterious automobile crash involving an escaped killer, The Ties That Bind…and Entangle traces how loyalty, notoriety, and tragedy kept the Kimes name in Oklahoma headlines long after the guns went silent.

The episode closes on one of the family’s darkest years—1932—when Nellie’s near-fatal shooting and another family member’s sudden, tragic death drew the brothers out of prison once more, setting the stage for the next storm in the Kimes saga.

Chapters:

00:00 – Episode 5 Recap

00:51 – Matt Kimes Saved from the Electric Chair

04:18 – Life Behind Bars – Reform under Warden Van Dyke 06:57 – Nellie Kimes and the Weight of Notoriety

09:52 – The Ada Accident and an Escaped Killer

11:54 – Nellie’s Near-Fatal Shooting

13:37 – Another Tragic Kimes Death

15:11 – Episode 7 Preview – Storm on the Horizon

About Dust Toll:

A 10-episode true-crime audio series uncovering the untold saga of the Kimes family - a story of loyalty, consequence, and the American outlaw spirit. Every episode draws from realy newspaper archives of the era.

New episodes released regularly.

Subscribe for the next chapter

Theme song: "A Lazy Farmer Boy" by Buster Carter and Preston Young, 1931

Tags

Dust Toll, Kimes Brothers, Matthew Kimes, Oklahoma History, True Crime Podcast, Historical Crime, Bank Robbery, Beggs Oklahoma, 1920s Outlaws, Phantom Bandit, Dust Toll Podcast

Even with both George and Matthew Kimes behind bars, the shadow of their name still loomed over Oklahoma. In this episode, the focus turns to the Kimes sister Nellie — and to the father whose own tragic fate would deepen the family’s legacy of crime, sorrow, and survival.

🎧 Listen to the full Dust Toll series at DustToll.com

📜 Chapters

00:00 – Episode 4 Recap

01:00 – Nellie’s Ordeal

02:07 – The Dying Farmer

04:49 – “Just a Girl, but Badly Abused”

08:40 – Trial and Release: A Family Under Fire

10:09 – The Liquor Raid

15:24 – Conflicting Accounts and Shady Lawmen

17:45 – Wrap Up and Episode 6 Preview

📜 About Dust TollA 10-episode true-crime audio series uncovering the untold saga of the Kimes family—a story of loyalty, consequence, and the American outlaw spirit.Every episode draws from real newspaper archives of the era.

🎙 New episodes released regularly

🔔 Subscribe for the next chapter → @DustToll

Theme song: "A Lazy Farmer Boy" by Buster Carter and Preston Young, 1931

🔖 TagsDust Toll, Kimes Brothers, Matthew Kimes, Oklahoma History, True Crime Podcast, Historical Crime, Bank Robbery, Beggs Oklahoma, 1920s Outlaws, Phantom Bandit, Dust Toll Podcast

The manhunt peaks, the legend grows.

Matthew “the Phantom Bandit” Kimes slips through disguises and roadblocks, kidnaps a marshal at shotgun point, and vanishes into the Osage Hills—only to reappear on the rim of the Grand Canyon. His capture ignites a media frenzy, a motion picture, and a trial that decides his fate - for now.

🩸 In This Episode

🕰 Chapters

00:00 – Previous Episode Recap

01:00 – The Phantom’s Elusive Game

05:21 – The Oilton Buick and the Baby · Marshal McAninch Abduction

07:50 – Manhunt in the Osage Hills

09:58 – Grand Canyon Sting – “I Quit, Fellows”

12:42 – The Journey Back to Oklahoma

14:16 – The Phantom Bandit on the Silver Screen

16:20 – The Beggs Trial – Alibi vs. Eyewitness

22:08 – Verdict and Sentence

23:36 – Next Time on Dust Toll

📜 About Dust Toll

A 10-episode true-crime audio series uncovering the untold saga of the Kimes family—a story of loyalty, consequence, and the American outlaw spirit.Every episode draws from real newspaper archives of the 1920s Midwest.🎙 New episodes released regularly

🔔 Subscribe for the next chapter → @DustToll

Theme song: "A Lazy Farmer Boy" by Buster Carter and Preston Young, 1931

🔖 TagsDust Toll, Kimes Brothers, Matthew Kimes, Oklahoma History, True Crime Podcast, Historical Crime, Bank Robbery, Beggs Oklahoma, 1920s Outlaws, Phantom Bandit, Dust Toll Podcast